Showing posts with label alternative energy. Show all posts
Showing posts with label alternative energy. Show all posts

Friday, June 29, 2007

Drop the fission line

Friday 29 June 2007
(URL for source to be found)
From Courier Mail, QLD, Australia

IMGP6918

Smart State ambassador Ian Lowe warns against a nuclear future

THE Queensland ALP conference this weekend offers an important forum for the Beattie Government to steer the state away from the risks of a radioactive future and towards sustainable energy options.

Prime Minister John Howard is actively promoting nuclear power as a belated answer to global climate change. Recent media reports suggest a wider federal nuclear agenda for Queensland that includes uranium enrichment and nuclear power.



Against this background it is important Premier Peter Beattie continues to keep the door firmly shut on uranium mining and the nuclear industry.

Uranium mining in Queensland would be economically short-sighted and environmentally disastrous. If we want to be the Smart State, we must use solar energy and other forms of renewables.

We should move towards better efficiency, turning our energy more effectively into the services we want. There are many more jobs and dollars in becoming a world leader in clean energy.

We have known for more than 20 years that burning coal, oil and gas is changing the global climate. Moves by the coal industry to clean up its act and reduce its pollution are welcome, but rushed pledges of taxpayer funding to assist this are not. The same money would do much more to curb greenhouse pollution if it were allocated to efficiency improvements and clean energy.

Some claim nuclear energy could help to slow climate change, but this is not a sensible solution. Even the Switkowski report, put together by a hand-picked group of pro-nuclear technocrats, did not make a convincing case.

The summary was optimistic, but the fine print of the report shows it would take about 15 years to build one nuclear power station if we started today, and the cost of electricity would more than double.

Even the most fanciful crash program, dotting 25 nuclear power stations all over the landscape, would only slow the growth in greenhouse pollution by less than 20 per cent. The science shows we need to make serious cuts, 60-90 per cent by 2050, not allow more increases.

Would uranium exports be an economic bonanza? No. The most optimistic forecast of the possible export income is about a third of our earnings from cheese exports. Uranium accounts for only about 1 per cent of our mineral exports and there is little prospect of it becoming a big earner.

What would be the cost of mining and exporting uranium? Huge volumes of radioactive mine tailings, depleted and degraded water resources and an increased risk from nuclear weapons and waste. We are still living with the legacy of the mines at Mary Kathleen and across the Northern Territory border at Rum Jungle.

Uranium mining needs large volumes of water -- not easy to find in Queensland at the moment -- and uses vast amounts of fossil energy, actually worsening greenhouse pollution.

Finally, as the Ranger uranium report said 30 years ago, uranium exports inevitably produce high-level radioactive waste that will have to be managed for hundreds of thousands of years and equally inevitably increase the risk of nuclear weapons.

Even if we say we have the best safeguards in the world and only export to the most responsible leaders, they won't be in power forever and can't control what others will do with the fissile material we sell.

We should learn the lesson of Iran. The world is now getting nervous about its possible nuclear developments. Thirty years ago, we were being urged to export uranium to Iran, and the US was trying to sell its nuclear technology to the Shah. Had that deal gone ahead, Iran would now have all it needs to build nuclear weapons.

The report A Bright Future showed we could get 25 per cent of our power from a mix of renewables by 2020. We should use solar hot water universally. Going that way would create literally thousands of real, skilled and permanent jobs in regional Australia.

Rather than facing a future of leaking tailings dams and increased pressure for nuclear reactors and waste dumps, Queensland can lead Australia and the world in sustainable and clean energy solutions.

The smart sunshine state is a much better option than being a toxic quarry.

Before last year's state election, the Premier stood firmly against the nuclear lobby and promised that the state would not support the mining or processing of uranium.

Beattie also resisted the silly suggestion that we should allow others to inflict on Queensland other stages of uranium processing, such as enrichment or dumping waste. As a Smart State ambassador, I strongly urge the Premier to resist those who want to drag us back into the Dark Age of uranium mining.

Ian Lowe is emeritus professor of science, technology and society at Griffith University and president of the Australian Conservation Foundation






...

Read the article.

Read More......

Sunday, May 06, 2007

Power station harnesses Sun's rays

Wednesday, 2 May 2007
From BBC (UK)

There is a scene in one of the Austin Powers films where Dr Evil unleashes a giant "tractor beam" of energy at Earth in order to extract a massive payment.

Well, the memory of it kept me chuckling as I toured the extraordinary scene of the new solar thermal power plant outside Seville in southern Spain.

From a distance, as we rounded a bend and first caught sight of it, I couldn't believe the strange structure ahead of me was actually real.

A concrete tower - 40 storeys high - stood bathed in intense white light, a totally bizarre image in the depths of the Andalusian countryside.

The tower looked like it was being hosed with giant sprays of water or was somehow being squirted with jets of pale gas. I had trouble working it out.

In fact, as we found out when we got closer, the rays of sunlight reflected by a field of 600 huge mirrors are so intense they illuminate the water vapour and dust hanging in the air.

...

Read the article.

Read More......

Thursday, April 26, 2007

The True Costs of NUCLEAR POWER

April/May 2006
From Mother Earth News

IMGP9090

The upshot is that nuclear power is seven times less cost-effective at displacing carbon than the cheapest, fastest alternative better energy efficiency, according to studies by the Rocky Mountain Institute. For example, a nuclear power plant typically costs at least $2 billion, or up to $5 billion with overruns. That money could be spent to insulate drafty buildings, purchase hybrid cars or install superefficient light bulbs and clothes dryers. Such an investment would lead to seven times less carbon consumption than if that money were spent on a nuclear power plant. In short, energy efficiency offers a much bigger bang for the buck. In a world of limited capital, investing in nuclear power will divert money away from cheaper and faster responses to global warming, thus slowing the worlds withdrawal from carbon fuels at a time when speed is essential.

...

Read the full article.

Read More......

Wednesday, April 25, 2007

Risk ahead: overheating planet or nuclear disaster?

April 2007
From The Age (Aust)

IMGP4732.JPG

This post links to an interesting debate about Nuclear Energy in Australia. Climate Action Brisbane does not support Nuclear Energy for Australia. It may be relevant in other places in the world where they lack the alternatives, though in Australia we have many alternatives. Specifically, why we don't agree with Nuclear Energy for Australia for these reasons:


  • we have enormous amounts of sunshine and wind (all across the country - this distribution helps with baseload requirements),
  • we don't have much spare water which is required for Nuclear Energy
  • it would take a long time to have a nuclear reactor up and running in Australia - time we don't have with the Climate Crisis hanging over our heads
  • the cost to build a reactor is enourmous
  • the cost to decomission a reactor is many times bigger though we don't fully know because this has not been done anywhere in the world
  • Uranium mining takes enormous amounts of energy and disturbs the carbon locked up in the ground, releasing it into the atmosphere
  • Transporting the ore takes considerable energy
  • Processing Uranium takes enormous amounts of energy, and as the amount of high-grade Uranium reduces, the cost to process less-pure forms requires more and more energy
  • Nuclear proliferation is a real posssibility when Nuclear Energy and reactors are considered the norm along with all the radioactive wastes they produce
  • A de-centralised model of energy generation is much more efficient and will produce far more jobs over a wide area rather than concentrated in one area. By spreading out our energy production we lessen the damage caused by a malfunction at any big centralised energy production centers (think terrorists here). Decentralised energy means that people are more in touch with where their energy comes from and will assist them to understand conservation and being more lean. (See "There is no shortage of energy" in ZMag: Global Warming: Limits of Solar and Wind Power)
  • the world is moving away from Nuclear Energy - Germany is switching away from nuclear to solar for example
  • did I mention that Australia has abundant solar and wind energy available to be tapped.
  • because Nuclear and Clean Coal is what big business wants and is just wrong. These people don't get it. We have to change how we view the world. But no this statement does not mean we will be travelling around by horse and cart (for starters this is a very inefficient form of transport). It means that we will be leading leaner lives. It means that we will grow and eat more food locally. It means that we will have a greater use of decentralised water gathering (rainwater tanks, gray water systems) and more decentralised energy producing centers. It means that we must learn to accept other people. It means that there will be less need for agression, war and the military in general.


Read the article.

Read More......

Thursday, March 29, 2007

A new architecture for our environment

Read the article by George Monbiot that inspired this post.

This blog has talked about biofuels before. Not much, but it is an important environmental issue to consider.

The issues around Biofuels highlights why holistic plans are needed that address all aspects that are to be considered. In engineering practices, you ALWAYS gather all known requirements, known risks and known restrictions together (to some level) before making any plans. This Biofuels issue shows an idea has been taken and run with, without considering all requirements.

Engineering plans start by building an architecture that all sub-systems can exist within. The global environmental problems require a new architecture to be built around how our planet operates. We have a bit of time, but we should start now and use this time to get it RIGHT.

Take building a bridge. Some groups of people may want a giant 200 meter tall structure that has 8 lanes. The restriction may be that the geology on the banks will not support such a weight, with the geology only able to support 4 lanes. We have a similar restriction - we can't support the number of cars (and the population) we have at the current resource level consumption.

The architecture we need to build in this case will support all aspects of our environmental problems. I can suggest the following requirements and restrictions that will go towards forming our environmental architecture (and that impact on the choice of biofuels):


  • Support for alternate fuels to reduce consumption of fossil fuels
  • Reduce number of vehicles
  • Increase transport by walking, cycling etc...
  • Reduce deforestation
  • Stop continued growth of world population
  • Reduce species loss
  • Reduce water usage
  • Encourage local farming
  • Reduce energy use
  • Increase energy efficiency
  • Happy and healthy citizens


The world cannot keep going at the current pace. And before mother nature bitch slaps us to the ground, we should consider all these requirements and more before building any solutions.

Read More......

Sunday, March 04, 2007

Flannery: Clean coal may not be viable

February 14, 2007
From Sydney Mornign Hearald (Aust)

Australian of the Year and leading scientist Dr Tim Flannery has questioned the viability of clean coal technology, saying it may be made redundant by cheaper and greener energy resources.


Dr Flannery told the Australian Workers Union (AWU) biannual meeting on the Gold Coast there was a need to switch to low emission energy sources.

He was greeted with hearty applause from the 200 delegates - something which surprised the scientist who has been accused in the media of wanting to shut down the nation's coal industry.

He dismissed the claims as entirely untrue but admitted he had some reservations about the viability of clean coal technology, which is Queensland Premier Peter Beattie's preferred option to reduce gas emissions.

He said Australia did not possess the right geological conditions to support the clean coal process, which injected carbon dioxide emissions into the ground rather than releasing them into the atmosphere.

"Globally there has got to be some areas where clean coal will work out, so I think there will always be a coal export industry (for Australia)," he said.

"Locally in Australia because of particular geological issues and because of the competition from cleaner and cheaper energy alternatives, I'm not 100 per cent sure clean coal is going to work out for our domestic market."

Australian of the Year and leading scientist Dr Tim Flannery has questioned the viability of clean coal technology, saying it may be made redundant by cheaper and greener energy resources.

Dr Flannery told the Australian Workers Union (AWU) biannual meeting on the Gold Coast there was a need to switch to low emission energy sources.

He was greeted with hearty applause from the 200 delegates - something which surprised the scientist who has been accused in the media of wanting to shut down the nation's coal industry.

He dismissed the claims as entirely untrue but admitted he had some reservations about the viability of clean coal technology, which is Queensland Premier Peter Beattie's preferred option to reduce gas emissions.

He said Australia did not possess the right geological conditions to support the clean coal process, which injected carbon dioxide emissions into the ground rather than releasing them into the atmosphere.

"Globally there has got to be some areas where clean coal will work out, so I think there will always be a coal export industry (for Australia)," he said.

"Locally in Australia because of particular geological issues and because of the competition from cleaner and cheaper energy alternatives, I'm not 100 per cent sure clean coal is going to work out for our domestic market."

However, Dr Flannery said Australia possessed the right conditions to make geothermal technology, using underground energy to produce electricity, while solar power was becoming increasingly viable.

The cost of geothermal-produced electricity would be similar to that of electricity produced by coal-fired power stations, Dr Flannery said, but he dismissed claims of a cost blow-out linked to alternative energy.

Dr Flannery agreed with the sentiments of British scientist Dr David King that climate change was a bigger global threat than terrorism and called on the Australian government to act immediately.

"They need to be getting a war footing using some of the budget surplus to start the building infrastructure to get on the transition path to lower emissions energy as soon as possible," Dr Flannery said.

"Economists may tell you that it will take 20 years but when there is a war on you get it done in a few years so we need to act quickly."


Read the article.

Read More......

Flannery tells industry: climate change can be slowed

14 February , 2007
From ABC National "PM" (Aust)

MARK COLVIN: The Australian of the Year, Professor Tim Flannery, has told members of the Australian Workers Union that it's still not too late for their industries to slow the pace of climate change.

The AWU represents workers from many of the country's highest energy users, including steel, gold and aluminium mines among them.

Today at the AWU's national conference on Queensland's Gold Coast, Professor Flannery described how chances to arrest the effects of climate change have been lost in the past, and recommended ways that the unionists could make a difference in the future.

Among his possible solutions, investing in Australia's untapped resources of geothermal and solar energy.

Alison Caldwell reports.

...

Read the article.

Read More......

Wednesday, February 14, 2007

Flannery: Government has been dragging the chain

"Tim Flannery called for the cessation of coal exports, something which was taken on board by the Greens but rejected by both Labor and the coalition."

"Professor Flannery urged Australians to make climate change a key issue in the coming Federal elections"

It would seem Labor and Liberal / National Party are not the choice for us to make if we are serious about tackling climate change. And Climate Change IS SERIOUS. This is not the tip of the iceberg, it is the base. The tip was:


  • Acid rain
  • Ozone Hole
  • Rainforest destruction
  • Poisoned rivers
  • Devistated fish stocks
  • Cancerous growths on Tasmanian Devils
  • ...

It's time to listen to the environmentalists (The "Greenies") who for decade have been saying that it is time to do something. Let's do it and realise that we have to make changes to our lifestyles - serious changes. Start by voting out the Liberal government in October 2007 (that is the suggested date).


Feb 13, 2007
From Epoch Times (USA).

Prominent environmentalist Professor Tim Flannery has not wasted any chances in raising awareness about the plight of the environment since receiving his Australian of the Year award last month.

While Professor Flannery is a well-known author, is part of the Wentworth Group of Concerned Scientists, and is also the director of the South Australian Museum he now finds himself in a position to be able to direct much of the debate and public concern over the environment.

After receiving the Australian of the Year honour from Prime Minister John Howard he said that: "This award means I have an obligation to the people of Australia to continue the quest to create a sustainable future for our country and for our children."

In the time since receiving the award Professor Flannery has not hesitated to criticise the Federal Government's environmental policies.

"There's no doubt this Government has been dragging the chain," he told the ABC.

"I've said in the past that Australia has been the worst of the worst in terms of addressing climate change, but I'm hopeful that we'll see...some movement."

Speaking via satellite last weekend at the launch of Virgin Earth Challenge, a multi-million dollar competition to encourage new ways to capture existing carbon dioxide in the atmosphere, Professor Flannery urged Australians to make climate change a key issue in the coming Federal elections.

"This year, all Australians have to become focused on the solution and making sure that we elect a government that is extremely serious about tackling this issue in the most vigorous manner that we can manage," Professor Flannery said reported the Sydney Morning Herald.

"This issue now is defined as the single largest issue in terms of the looming election…I am very much focused on trying to get a good outcome for my country, trying to see us pole-vault out from the laggard list into a leading player in this climate-change debate."

It is the boldest step into the political arena by the environmentalist. A few days earlier the Professor called for the cessation of coal exports, something which was taken on board by the Greens but rejected by both Labor and the coalition.

Professor Flannery told media that Australia's exporting of coal could no longer be considered to be in the country's national interest.

However, the Prime Minister responded by saying: "We can't have knee-jerk reactions."

"Much as I respect Tim Flannery, I saw him this morning talking about effectively stopping coal exports. You can't do that. That would be devastating to many communities throughout Australia," he told Sky News. Australia is the world's largest coal exporter.

While his comments regarding coal exports made headlines, the Professor, has said that there has been not enough attention placed upon the cleaner technology of geothermal energy that he believes could have the potential to be a replacement energy source.

Geothermal energy, the ABC reports, is the conversion of heat buried deep beneath the earth into electricity. Supporters for this type of technology that is the only known renewable energy source that is able to carry large base loads, potentially providing a constant source of power.

However, it is said to be years away from being able to be a viable energy supply.

Meanwhile one thing seems certain, the museum director has turned into an international climate-change warrior, and with a whole year ahead, there is surely more to come.

Read the article.

Read More......

Sunday, February 04, 2007

Truth about biofuels

January 26, 2007
From Guardian (UK).

The urgent need for action to avoid the worst effects of climate change is leading to an ever wider range of proposed solutions. Some are potentially problematic, however. In seeking to solve one environmental problem, we could make others worse.

This week President Bush announced plans to reduce dependence on imported petrol through a dramatic increase in biofuel production. This particular option is politically attractive because it can be presented as a means for us all to have our carbon cake and eat it. Instead of changing our driving habits, we can simply change the fuel source, or so it is implied.

"Biofuel" is the term used to describe a range of plant-based alternatives to diesel and petrol. The yellow-flowered oil seed rape that we grow in the UK is one source - in that case for biodiesel. Others include sugar cane (to make ethanol, a petrol alternative), soya and oil palm.


Biofuels can contribute an environmental benefit in the form of reduced overall carbon dioxide emissions from transport. This is because when plants grow they take carbon dioxide from the air. Burning fuel from the plants in engines is thus a temporary contribution, but only so long as new crops are planted to take the same amount of carbon dioxide out of the air again. So far so good: but there are big problems.

Biofuel cultivation needs land - lots of it - and demand for land for fuel production can place pressure on land that is important for conservation. In Brazil, the cultivation of sugar cane to make ethanol has led to large-scale forest loss. The rapid recent expansion of soya production for food (and animal feed) is already causing high levels of forest loss and if soya is additionally grown to make biofuel then the devastating changes in land use that have taken place in recent years could actually accelerate - in order to make what some would present as "green" fuel.

In Indonesia and Malaysia there has similarly been a major expansion in the planting of oil palms, both to provide a source of cheap fat for the food industry and increasingly as a source of fuel for vehicles. The spread of palm-oil plantations has not only been responsible for massive environmental destruction, but has also led to serious social impacts, including conflicts over land and the abuse of workers.

Then there are questions linked to the energy used in the cultivation, processing and distribution of biofuels. Fossil energy is used in agricultural machinery, and in converting crops into fuel. There is also a major fossil-energy input in the production of fertilisers and pesticides used to grow the biofuels. All this leads to carbon dioxide emissions. So does transporting biofuel to market. If biofuels are transported around the world, and made with fossil energy, then their overall environmental benefit will be considerably reduced. If they are also cultivated at the expense of ancient rainforests, then the climate-change impact might be actually worse than using petrol or diesel.

If we are to reap benefits from biofuels, we need some environmental safeguards, such as protection for important ecosystems, and regulation of production methods and the energy used in manufacturing and distribution. It seems to me that a certification scheme is needed so that companies such as BP and Shell, who will be selling this stuff, could show what level of environmental benefit (if any) is actually being achieved, both in terms of land use and savings in carbon dioxide emissions.

Even if we do end up with an effective certification scheme, the emphasis must remain firmly on greener motoring based on efficiency first, and on alternative fuels second. Filling up a huge Range Rover with 5.7% biofuel (which is the target the EU has set and which is now being implemented in the UK) can hardly be seen as a sound environmental choice when there are cars that are more than twice as efficient than these gas guzzling monsters.

By all means let's have 5.7% and upwards of environmentally sound biofuel, but let's make sure we are doing all we can to use it in really efficient engines. At Friends of the Earth we believe a good start would be for the EU to put in place some legally binding fuel efficiency standards on vehicle manufacturers who have so far failed to rise to the challenge. President Bush might like to do the same, and to encourage his country's citizens to use their cars less.

Read the article.

Also see




Read More......

Saturday, February 03, 2007

Carbon Tax - Canada's Green Industrial Revolution

25/1/07 10:36AM
From http://www.huffstrategy.com.

Powering Canada's Green Industrial Revolution

Canadian action on climate change is unfocused, ineffective and way too complicated.

There is, however, a straightforward mechanism that, with fairness, predictability and certainty, would put a substantial cork in our carbon emissions.

This cork is a simple carbon tax that would harness $15 billion a year to pave Canada's path toward a green industrial revolution based on a low-carbon economy.

First, a basic fact: In 2004, nearly 50 per cent of Canada's total greenhouse gas (GHG) emissions were courtesy of just a few hundred facilities.

It is much easier to corral emissions from these large facilities than to round up Canada's 18.2 million passenger cars and trucks, which accounted for only 9.7 per cent of Canada's 2004 GHG emissions.

Here's how it would work.

Announce that, effective in 2008, all extractive industry and power generating large final emitters in Canada would be levied an initial modest tax of $30 per tonne of CO2 equivalent (CO2e). This would be accompanied by a specific schedule of the carbon tax's rise over the coming decades.

The monies flowing from this tax would be pigeonholed into each facility's individual trust accounts and managed by the 'Carbon Innovation Fund' (CIF). The legal rights to this money would not belong to the government, but the facility itself, with certain provisions.

...

Read the article.

Read More......

Friday, February 02, 2007

End of the Road for Hydrogen

Written by Anthony Day, (c) Copyright 2007, http://www.anthony-day.co.uk
Thursday, 25 January 2007
From http://www.planetsave.com

With climate change on everyone’s mind and rumours of an energy crisis, what could be better than a car which doesn’t run on fossil fuels and has no emissions except water? BMW’s new Hydrogen 7 fits the bill. This is the V-12 BMW 7 modified to run on hydrogen. It has a petrol tank as well; it also runs on petrol, which is handy if you are far from the UK’s only hydrogen filling station – one of only six in the world. Of course, if hydrogen catches on there will be filling stations all over the country, won’t there?

Hydrogen cars sound ideal, but there are practical problems. First, the hydrogen tank takes eight minutes to fill and it takes up most of the boot space. Even then, the hydrogen tank provides a range of only 125 miles. To get enough hydrogen into the fuel tank it has to be chilled and liquefied. Gradually it warms up and boils away, so if you don’t use the car over the weekend you’ll find less in the tank. Park up at the airport while you take your three-week holiday and when you get back it’ll be nearly empty.

he fact that the hydrogen has to boil off for safety reasons may be why hydrogen vehicles are illegal in France. Even over here you are advised not to park the vehicle in an enclosed car park. You cannot see hydrogen, you cannot smell it and it burns with an invisible flame. Like petrol vapour, when mixed with air it is highly explosive. At least you can smell petrol!

Where does hydrogen come from? It is either extracted from natural gas or electrolysed by passing a current through water. Extracting hydrogen from natural gas leaves carbon dioxide, which must be captured – otherwise the process produces as much CO2 emissions as if you had just burnt the gas. Electrolysis produces no CO2, but it does produce a lot of waste heat so the energy content of the hydrogen is significantly less than the energy of the electricity used. Electricity itself comes from coal, gas or nuclear, and the electricity produced is also much less than the fuel put into the generation process. Producing hydrogen this way is very inefficient.

All these factors make it very doubtful that hydrogen will be the fuel of the future. As we approach Peak Oil and petrol becomes more and more expensive, economies and cutting back on our travel will be the only solution.

How will you change your lifestyle when petrol costs £5/litre? (That’s $36.95 per US gallon.)

Read the article.

Read More......