Showing posts with label carbon rationing. Show all posts
Showing posts with label carbon rationing. Show all posts

Sunday, November 16, 2008

Carbon crash hits Europe's emission trading scheme

November 06, 2008
From The Australian

WalkAgainstWarming200860
This is why we should have a straight carbon tax or carbon rationing instead of relying on the ETS Market system which is just capitalism which has caused the problems in the first place.

A Carbon Tax is where a GST / VAT / .. type tax at some percent is applied calculated on the cost it will take to repair that Carbon that has been emmitted in manufacturing, transporting etc... the product in question. It would be calculated and not a plucked figure.

Carbon rationing is even better where we work out how much carbon per person we're allowed to emit to remain sustainable. It will involve some credit card type arrangement. If you use more than your allocation you can buy from someone who didn't use as much.

Both are politically difficult to implement in our current capitalist societies.


WHILE you were distracted by crashing banks and clashing US senators, you may have missed a small environmental earthquake.

The price of carbon has collapsed.

In only three months, life has become a lot cheaper for polluters. The financial cost of warming the planet has plummeted in Europe's emissions trading system (ETS) and the effectiveness of such a volatile market mechanism in curbing carbon is being questioned.

You may recall that the ETS is a mechanism to encourage businesses to reduce their carbon output. Europe's larger companies are allocated permits to emit CO2, and these allowances, called EUAs, can be traded on exchanges.

Companies that emit less CO2 than their allocation can sell EUAs for cash, but inefficient polluters must buy EUAs or face financial penalties.

The idea is that a shortfall in EUAs allocated by governments will cause the carbon price to rise, stimulating investment in carbon reduction.

It's a market solution to pollution, but this carbon market is showing a distressing tendency to behave like most financial markets -- hysterically. In July, the right to spew out one tonne of CO2 from a chimney would have cost a power generator E29.33, but yesterday it could be bought for only E18.25 ($34.14).


...

Read the article.

Read More......

Tuesday, September 18, 2007

Carbon Rationing - becoming reality

Monday September 10 2007
From Guardian (UK)

Rationing project tests government plans to make pollution personal



Plans for the world's first personal carbon trading scheme, in which people buy and sell their rights to produce pollution, are unveiled today.

The Royal Society for the Encouragement of Arts, Manufactures & Commerce (RSA) is piloting a project later this year to test whether personal carbon trading could work on a large scale.

The idea, also called carbon rationing, is being considered by the government as a radical way to curb emissions of greenhouse gases such as carbon dioxide from households and consumers. Matt Prescott, who runs the RSA project, said: "Personal carbon trading is a way to bridge the gap between individual and collective action. It would be a way for the government to give people a sense of purpose in their efforts to reduce their emissions."

Under the initiative, due to start in November, participants will enter details of their energy use into a computer system, which already tracks the emissions of 5,000 RSA volunteers. Each person will be allocated a cap on their carbon dioxide use, and will be forced to buy credits from others if they exceed it.

Within a year, the RSA hopes to link their computer system to the billing procedures of gas and electricity companies, so the energy use of volunteers can be tracked automatically. They are also talking to oil companies about obtaining details of fuel purchases. The society hopes to have tens of thousands of people trading carbon credits for cash within three years.

Officials in the environment department, Defra, are giving carbon rationing serious thought. The RSA project was launched last year by the former environment secretary, David Miliband, who talked of people carrying carbon credit cards to be swiped when they bought fuel or flights. Today's report says the government could introduce compulsory carbon trading by 2013, using the climate change bill to change the law.

Read the article.

Read More......

Thursday, May 10, 2007

Blitz spirit needed to face threat of climate change

Wednesday May 9, 2007
From Guardian (UK)

The government's climate change bill has nowhere near the vision commensurate to the scale of the threat. The Stern Review has already set out the facts: we can carry on as we are, leading to a global economic collapse, or we can try to halt the worst ravages of climate change by stabilising CO2 at 450 parts per million (ppm) in the atmosphere, or we can aim to stabilise CO2 at 500-550 ppm.

...

Read the article.

Read More......

Tuesday, January 30, 2007

A Guide To Carbon Trading

24th January 2007,
From Catalyst Commercial (UK).

From the point of view of mitigating climate change, the key question is whether carbon trading will actually reduce carbon emissions. Radical critics, such as Larry Lohmann of the environmental and social NGO the Corner House, argue that trading itself adds nothing to emissions reductions efforts. Certainly, what emerges from closer examination of air pollution trading schemes in general is that their effectiveness depends heavily on scheme design. One issue is the strength or weakness of the underlying curbs set on emissions. In the case of the EU scheme, Cambridge economist Michael Grubb makes the point that its sheer scale means that member states are subject to intense lobbying by economically strategic industries. In the first phase of the scheme, lobbyists across Europe pushed successfully for weak caps. In April 2006, when it became clear that 20 of the 25 member states had set caps for 2005 that were so generous that they were above actual emissions the carbon price immediately collapsed from €25 to around €4 per tonne, where it currently languishes.

Industrial lobbyists also argued successfully for “grandfathering” for allocations to particular installations to be based on their emissions in a reference period rather than on an overall carbon target, as under Kyoto, or on best practice in the industry. If this is repeated in subsequent phases, it will create a perverse incentive for companies to increase emissions, because this will give them a higher allocation in the next phase. In the run-up to the second phase, industrial lobbyists are also arguing for the right to carry over excess credits from the first phase. Member states have placated these interests by adopting complex non-transparent procedures, and in many cases simply by stalling on submitting plans to the point where the commission was threatening legal action in late 2006.

How disastrous is this experience for the EU ETS? Defenders of the scheme say that many of the concessions made to industry weak caps, grandfathering, and other weaknesses like the small fines for non-compliance are politically necessary to get the scheme launched. Once it is running, caps and other features can be tightened. It is true that the first phase of the European scheme was seen as a trial period. But is it credible that the second phase will see a tougher stance? Late last year the commission sent back all the member states’ proposals (with the exception of Britain’s) because they were too lax, but it remains to be seen if governments and their industrial lobbies will play ball.

Similar issues of political credibility would also apply to personal carbon trading. Will people believe a government that says it intends to progressively cut the personal carbon allowance would actually carry out such an unpopular policy or stay in power if it did.

A second concern about the European scheme is that the cap is not only weak but also leaky. Companies that need extra credits to cover their carbon emissions can not only buy them in the market, but can also acquire them by investing in clean development mechanism (CDM) projects the offsetting scheme set up under the Kyoto protocol. How many reduction credits can be acquired in this way varies from country to country, but it is expected that they will make up the majority.

In theory, the CDM is just an extension of the flexibility approach. A tonne of carbon dioxide emissions abated has the same effect anywhere in the world. So if it is cheaper to do this in India or Africa than in Europe, why not do so, especially if, as originally advertised, the CDM also helps transfer renewable energy technologies to the south?
In practice, renewable energy is involved in only 2 per cent of CDM projects. More typical is the deal announced last September, where Centrica (the parent company of British Gas) is investing in technology for capturing emissions of the very potent greenhouse gas HFC-23 from a Chinese chemical company. Some 70 per cent of CDM credits arise from capture projects like this one (arranged by the London-based carbon trading investment bank Climate Change Capital), mainly involving large industrial plants in China, India, Brazil and Korea.

...

Read the article.

Read More......

Climate change must be put on the front burner

Stephen McGrail
January 25, 2007
The Age

IF THERE is one issue that is forcing most businesses to think seriously about the future, it is climate change.

It is generating increased uncertainty. Australian companies wishing to plan effectively need new tools, processes and thinking to adapt and succeed.

For most of last year, one could understand companies considering climate change to be something they would worry about later, or as something for others to worry about.

Today, the context is different. This year, a "low-carbon future" is increasingly the priority of all: public, politicians and businessmen.

Waves of change are building that could join forces to become, in the words of futurist Jim Dator, "tsunamis of change". To Dator, people and organisations are too often standing with their backs to the metaphorical waves as they gather pace and become unforeseen tsunamis.

Consider these "three Ls": legislation, litigation and liability.

New climate change legislation has been recently proposed or passed by British Prime Minister Tony Blair, California "Governator" Arnold Schwarzenegger and in South Australia by Premier Mike Rann.

Rann's bill, the first of its kind in the southern hemisphere, introduces targets, a commitment to reducing greenhouse emissions and other programs and initiatives. Victoria won't be far behind, with Labor pledging similar legislation in the recent state election. This is only the start.

There has also been a gathering wave of the second "L", litigation.

Last September, California began legal action against the "big six" car companies. The action has been hailed as the most significant piece of climate change litigation. If successful, it will set an important legal precedent.

While the car industry is trying to play it down, some experts claim that if a big polluter knew it was damaging the environment and persisted, regardless, or denied the knowledge, it could be found as guilty as the tobacco giants that tried to hide what they knew about cancer.

In Australia, the NSW Land and Environment Court recently found that Centennial Coal, which planned an open-cut coalmine in the Hunter Valley, failed to assess properly its environmental impacts by not including a global warming assessment.

The judge found a connection between coalmining and climate change. Green groups were delighted, while the local Labor MP went ballistic at the news, claiming "extreme environmentalists are launching a jihad against the (coal) industry". This decision also gives real legal meaning to the principles of sustainable development embedded in many state and federal acts of Parliament.

It is worth noting that the Carbon Disclosure Project has been warning about the possibility of such litigation and multibillion-dollar climate change lawsuits for many years.

Our last "L", liability, is just as crucial. Companies need to understand and mitigate the potential for crippling financial carbon liabilities.

...

Read the article.

Read More......

The Low-Carbon Diet

(or how to lose half a tonne in just one month)



Sunday January 21, 2007
The Observer

Global warming is alarming, but there's no need to be defeatist: our future is in our own hands. Here Lucy Siegle offers 36 positive suggestions on how we can change our lives, reduce carbon emissions and help save the planet - all in the form of three simple and enticing menus, calculated not in calories but 'carbs'. And best of all, if you reduce your carbon footprint you can treat yourself, with a gloriously clear conscience

When I became the Observer Magazine's ethical living columnist two years ago I was inundated with questions from readers about recycling. Today, my postbag is still bursting with your questions, but now most of them concern spiralling carbon emissions. This only confirms what many of us now realise: that our addiction to a carbon-rich lifestyle is threatening the life of our planet. And, as everybody from Al Gore to Oprah Winfrey, the Archbishop of Canterbury, Nicholas Stern and even Arnold Schwarzenegger told us last year, we must all radically 'decarbonise' the way we live.

Article continues
If you follow the diet described below, you will be taking the first steps to reducing the size of the one thing you have direct control over - your carbon footprint. Almost every aspect of your life affects the size of your carbon footprint. Leaving some appliances plugged in, for instance, increases energy consumption, and this increases the amount of fossil fuels burnt in power stations, which affects the amount of CO2 emitted into the atmosphere. Other aspects of your lifestyle affect your carbon footprint in less obvious ways: your kids, for example, may have plastic toys produced in China - in which case China has emitted the CO2 on your behalf.

Responses to the CO2 problem vary. Tony Blair, fresh from occupying one of Robin Gibb's sun-loungers in Florida, recently pronounced curbs on long-haul flights 'impractical'. He's hoping technology will provide alternative, low-CO2 aviation fuels. But while he waits for Richard Branson to begin running a transatlantic fleet on hemp oil, the climate-change bomb is already ticking. A low-carbon lifestyle should begin inside your own four walls. Individuals are responsible for 85 per cent of the UK's total CO2 emissions. We therefore have the power to reduce emissions significantly by making low-carbon choices.

The past year has seen concentrations of CO2 in the atmosphere continue to soar, and they are set to increase by 2.5 per cent annually. This is leading the planet into uncharted territory: higher temperatures, rising tides, the destruction of ice shelves, drought, failing crops, the mass movement of climate change refugees. The alarm has been sounded, now is the time for action...

It is in this spirit that we have come up with this carbon-saving diet: a one-month detox to reduce your planet-destroying size-11 carbon footprint into a dainty size 4. Good luck.

What is a carb?

To make the diet user-friendly, we have developed our own unit of measurement: the carb. One carb represents 100g of CO2. The aim is to lose as many carbs as possible until you meet your target 'weight'. As the average person is responsible for emitting 11 tonnes of carbon a year we have divided this by 12 to produce a monthly figure of 9,167 carbs. This is your starting 'weight'.

...

Read the article.

Also see


It's carbon judgment day

Read More......

Monday, January 22, 2007

Royal Society Carbon Trading site

The Royal Society was founded in 1660 and claims to be the oldest learned society still in existence.

Past presidents include Sir Isaac Newton and Joseph Banks.

They, in this more modern time, have created a site called Carbon Limited that looks at our use of Carbon more from the perpective of carbon rationing (a concept discussed by George Monbiot in his book Heat).

On this site you can deduce your carbon emisions, learn ways to reduce them, and compare them to other people. If we are to achieve a 90% reduction in Greenhouse gas emisions by 2030 (See Heat), then we will all have to be concious of this information.

Read More......