Showing posts with label nuclear. Show all posts
Showing posts with label nuclear. Show all posts

Friday, June 29, 2007

Drop the fission line

Friday 29 June 2007
(URL for source to be found)
From Courier Mail, QLD, Australia

IMGP6918

Smart State ambassador Ian Lowe warns against a nuclear future

THE Queensland ALP conference this weekend offers an important forum for the Beattie Government to steer the state away from the risks of a radioactive future and towards sustainable energy options.

Prime Minister John Howard is actively promoting nuclear power as a belated answer to global climate change. Recent media reports suggest a wider federal nuclear agenda for Queensland that includes uranium enrichment and nuclear power.



Against this background it is important Premier Peter Beattie continues to keep the door firmly shut on uranium mining and the nuclear industry.

Uranium mining in Queensland would be economically short-sighted and environmentally disastrous. If we want to be the Smart State, we must use solar energy and other forms of renewables.

We should move towards better efficiency, turning our energy more effectively into the services we want. There are many more jobs and dollars in becoming a world leader in clean energy.

We have known for more than 20 years that burning coal, oil and gas is changing the global climate. Moves by the coal industry to clean up its act and reduce its pollution are welcome, but rushed pledges of taxpayer funding to assist this are not. The same money would do much more to curb greenhouse pollution if it were allocated to efficiency improvements and clean energy.

Some claim nuclear energy could help to slow climate change, but this is not a sensible solution. Even the Switkowski report, put together by a hand-picked group of pro-nuclear technocrats, did not make a convincing case.

The summary was optimistic, but the fine print of the report shows it would take about 15 years to build one nuclear power station if we started today, and the cost of electricity would more than double.

Even the most fanciful crash program, dotting 25 nuclear power stations all over the landscape, would only slow the growth in greenhouse pollution by less than 20 per cent. The science shows we need to make serious cuts, 60-90 per cent by 2050, not allow more increases.

Would uranium exports be an economic bonanza? No. The most optimistic forecast of the possible export income is about a third of our earnings from cheese exports. Uranium accounts for only about 1 per cent of our mineral exports and there is little prospect of it becoming a big earner.

What would be the cost of mining and exporting uranium? Huge volumes of radioactive mine tailings, depleted and degraded water resources and an increased risk from nuclear weapons and waste. We are still living with the legacy of the mines at Mary Kathleen and across the Northern Territory border at Rum Jungle.

Uranium mining needs large volumes of water -- not easy to find in Queensland at the moment -- and uses vast amounts of fossil energy, actually worsening greenhouse pollution.

Finally, as the Ranger uranium report said 30 years ago, uranium exports inevitably produce high-level radioactive waste that will have to be managed for hundreds of thousands of years and equally inevitably increase the risk of nuclear weapons.

Even if we say we have the best safeguards in the world and only export to the most responsible leaders, they won't be in power forever and can't control what others will do with the fissile material we sell.

We should learn the lesson of Iran. The world is now getting nervous about its possible nuclear developments. Thirty years ago, we were being urged to export uranium to Iran, and the US was trying to sell its nuclear technology to the Shah. Had that deal gone ahead, Iran would now have all it needs to build nuclear weapons.

The report A Bright Future showed we could get 25 per cent of our power from a mix of renewables by 2020. We should use solar hot water universally. Going that way would create literally thousands of real, skilled and permanent jobs in regional Australia.

Rather than facing a future of leaking tailings dams and increased pressure for nuclear reactors and waste dumps, Queensland can lead Australia and the world in sustainable and clean energy solutions.

The smart sunshine state is a much better option than being a toxic quarry.

Before last year's state election, the Premier stood firmly against the nuclear lobby and promised that the state would not support the mining or processing of uranium.

Beattie also resisted the silly suggestion that we should allow others to inflict on Queensland other stages of uranium processing, such as enrichment or dumping waste. As a Smart State ambassador, I strongly urge the Premier to resist those who want to drag us back into the Dark Age of uranium mining.

Ian Lowe is emeritus professor of science, technology and society at Griffith University and president of the Australian Conservation Foundation






...

Read the article.

Read More......

Thursday, April 26, 2007

The True Costs of NUCLEAR POWER

April/May 2006
From Mother Earth News

IMGP9090

The upshot is that nuclear power is seven times less cost-effective at displacing carbon than the cheapest, fastest alternative better energy efficiency, according to studies by the Rocky Mountain Institute. For example, a nuclear power plant typically costs at least $2 billion, or up to $5 billion with overruns. That money could be spent to insulate drafty buildings, purchase hybrid cars or install superefficient light bulbs and clothes dryers. Such an investment would lead to seven times less carbon consumption than if that money were spent on a nuclear power plant. In short, energy efficiency offers a much bigger bang for the buck. In a world of limited capital, investing in nuclear power will divert money away from cheaper and faster responses to global warming, thus slowing the worlds withdrawal from carbon fuels at a time when speed is essential.

...

Read the full article.

Read More......

Letters against Nucelar Energy / Uranium Mining

The following 2 letters are "letters to the editor". The source of the first was not indicated.

Letter One



There are numerous reasons why common sense dictates that we cannot
have uranium mining in Australia, the driest continent in the world. All uranium
mining operations require vast volumes of water in the process of extracting the
uranium from the uranium ore. The liquid waste comprising more than 97 percent
of the ore, and containing radioactive particles, heavy metals and acid would
either be dumped into the ground water, (as at the Beverly mine) or will be
stored recklessly in crudely built tailings dams, (as at the Olympic Uranium
Mining Dam) in the open air.(Olympic Uranium Dam uses/contaminates 42 million
litres of water per day).

The radionuclides and heavy metals which were previously inert and immobile in
the ore body, are after processing, bioavailable and mobile in the aquifier if
put into the ground water, or readily able to leak out of the tailings dams and
into our environment.

With 32 sites in Queensland alone where uranium has been found, such
dangerous tailings dams could well be positioned on Australia’s natural
cyclical flood plains, where no safeguards would ever be adequate for a period
of hundreds of thousands of years for which the tailings remain dangerously
radioactive, bioavailable and mobile. As well as leaking out and contaminating
other water, evaporation of leaked tailings can also occur which can then become
dust, or it may again precipitate as rainfall.

Such remote tailings dams could also become the targets of terrorist
attacks, or they could even become the source of easily available
contaminated radioactive water, for use by terrorists in a terrorist act,
whereby they use it to contaminate town water supplies. If a government is so
concerned about the possibility of terrorism, then it would not ever consider
uranium mining in a country with a nation wide water shortage problem.

(As an example of the relationship between Australia’s water and mining, it has
just been announced that more than 40 mines along the Murray-Darling River Basin
are going to be banned from using water from July 1st. So why should uranium
mines be any different? There are more reasons to prevent the use of water by
uranium mines than any other type of mine).

Not discussed for the sake of brevity are the issues of encouraging nuclear
proliferation, other forms of nuclear waste, the use of waste to produce
depleted uranium weapons, and their deadly contamination of the landscape in other
countries, as Australia’s negative contribution to a world which doesn’t need
nuclear power, when renewable energy sources can indeed provide adequate
baseload power.


Letter Two



No2. letter sent by Keith Jaffray, of Byfield to the Courier Mail.

Dear Sir,

Flat earthers,climate change sceptics,coconut heads and mercenary ghouls are
singing the praises of expanding the uranium industry..........It's time for us
to wake up and raise our individual and collective conscience.

Cetainly there are some beneficial uses of radiation such as for xrays and anti
cancer therapy.However,expanding the uranium industry to cater to a world greedy
for electricity is fraught with great danger. Most people are not aware that
"enriched uranium" creams off only 3% of the uranium from uranium ore for power
generation....the rest (97%) is radioactive waste and is called "depleted
uranium" or "d.u.".This is a misnoma.Depleted uranium has a half life of 4.5
billion years and any form of life exposed to this waste is facing a catostropic
future.Human beings develop the most horrific illnesses,tumours,chromosome
damage,birth deformaties and ultimately death. D.U. happens to be twice the
weight of lead and in a novel approach the producers of "enriched uranium"have
found a convenient way of disposing of the "waste"(depleted uranium) by giving
it to armaments manufacturers! It is now being used for armour plating in tanks
and as a replacement for lead in bullets,missiles and war heads.

U.S.A. military forces have been using D.U.weapons extensively in Iraq since the
1st Gulf War.Over 300,000 U.S.A. service personnel are on permanent dissability
pensions having developed "Gulf War Syndrome" after being exposed to their own
uranium dust on the battlefield. 11,000 of those service personnel have since
died from this "syndrome", not to mention the thousands of innocent Iraqis who
have been contaminated by this weapon of mass destruction declared illegal by
the United Nations.

Take a look at the photographic exhibition "Children of the Gulf War" when it is
displayed at a venue near you. Show some sympathy to our own Australian service
personnel who have been exposed to this evil poison (see"The Courier Mail" March
28th,2007).

The Australian Defence Forces purchased and used 43,000 rounds of D.U.amunition
over a period of 10 years in training exercises.How many Ausralian defence
personnel and civilians have been exposed to this radioactve poison?Is this
"Agent Orange" all over again? These are serious questions only capable of being
answered by a Commonwealth Commission of Inquiry.

Greedy, short sighted armaments manufacturers cannot be trusted to deal with
D.U..

Say "NO" to uranium mining - leave it in the ground.

Read More......

Wednesday, April 25, 2007

Risk ahead: overheating planet or nuclear disaster?

April 2007
From The Age (Aust)

IMGP4732.JPG

This post links to an interesting debate about Nuclear Energy in Australia. Climate Action Brisbane does not support Nuclear Energy for Australia. It may be relevant in other places in the world where they lack the alternatives, though in Australia we have many alternatives. Specifically, why we don't agree with Nuclear Energy for Australia for these reasons:


  • we have enormous amounts of sunshine and wind (all across the country - this distribution helps with baseload requirements),
  • we don't have much spare water which is required for Nuclear Energy
  • it would take a long time to have a nuclear reactor up and running in Australia - time we don't have with the Climate Crisis hanging over our heads
  • the cost to build a reactor is enourmous
  • the cost to decomission a reactor is many times bigger though we don't fully know because this has not been done anywhere in the world
  • Uranium mining takes enormous amounts of energy and disturbs the carbon locked up in the ground, releasing it into the atmosphere
  • Transporting the ore takes considerable energy
  • Processing Uranium takes enormous amounts of energy, and as the amount of high-grade Uranium reduces, the cost to process less-pure forms requires more and more energy
  • Nuclear proliferation is a real posssibility when Nuclear Energy and reactors are considered the norm along with all the radioactive wastes they produce
  • A de-centralised model of energy generation is much more efficient and will produce far more jobs over a wide area rather than concentrated in one area. By spreading out our energy production we lessen the damage caused by a malfunction at any big centralised energy production centers (think terrorists here). Decentralised energy means that people are more in touch with where their energy comes from and will assist them to understand conservation and being more lean. (See "There is no shortage of energy" in ZMag: Global Warming: Limits of Solar and Wind Power)
  • the world is moving away from Nuclear Energy - Germany is switching away from nuclear to solar for example
  • did I mention that Australia has abundant solar and wind energy available to be tapped.
  • because Nuclear and Clean Coal is what big business wants and is just wrong. These people don't get it. We have to change how we view the world. But no this statement does not mean we will be travelling around by horse and cart (for starters this is a very inefficient form of transport). It means that we will be leading leaner lives. It means that we will grow and eat more food locally. It means that we will have a greater use of decentralised water gathering (rainwater tanks, gray water systems) and more decentralised energy producing centers. It means that we must learn to accept other people. It means that there will be less need for agression, war and the military in general.


Read the article.

Read More......

Sunday, March 11, 2007

PM denies nuclear inquiry linked to big business


From ABC News (Aust)

This article discusses cronyism surrounding managing the climate change problem.

Our Prime Minister, John Howard, was a climate change denier until just before the Walk Against Warming last year (2006). Our group organised the Brisbane (Australia) event for this. It was held on November 4th, a very rainy day. Howard called the news about climate change "sensationalism" or similar. The pressure was too great, especially after the walk was held and he had to change his view to admit that it is true. The difference is that he may understand it to be true, but he doesn't believe it. He is not sincere to the changes that will come about due to it and the changes that need to be made to manage it. A very conservative man.

The so called world leaders started banging heads trying to tackle this problem and they amazingly decided that nuclear energy is the way to go. Howard is fully behind it. The article this links to talks about how Howard launched an inquiry into a nuclear powered australia and it just so happens that a mate of his has put together a plan on building a nuclear energy infrastructure in Australia. How convenient.

I agree that in many places in the world there are no valid alternatives, but in Australia we have oodles of sunshine, excessive amounts of wind, a giant coastline with lots of waves, geothermal power from hot rocks and so on. Nuclear does produce energy greenhouse gas (GHG) emission free, however the process also includes these nasties:


  • Mining of uranium takes enormous amounts of energy (producing GHG from fossil fuels to drive vehicles and coal) and always results in the poisoning of the local creeks, rivers and watertable;
  • Uranium processing also takes a lot of energy (GHGs mostly from coal that provides 80% of Australia's energy needs);
  • Transportation of the ore takes large amounts of energy (GHGs through fossil fueled engines)
  • In the 50 years that the world has had nuclear energy, NO SAFE METHOD OF DISPOSAL has been found, and the danger from the radiation lasts hundreds of thousands of years
  • The world is so fearful of terrorists. Surely a dirty bomb that uses nuclear waste is one of the scariest terror mechanism that terrorists could use


People need to understand ALL the facts before deciding what they want. I think if ALL the information is given to enough people, then nuclear power will never become a reality in Australia.

Read the article.

Read More......

Thursday, February 01, 2007

Coastal sites flagged for nuke reactors

Tuesday Jan 30 22:35 AEDT
From http://news.ninemsn.com.au

Nuclear reactors are likely to be spaced out along the Australian coast from Townsville in Queensland to Port Augusta in South Australia under a nuclear-powered future, a new study says.

Queensland would have six reactors and the coast around Sydney from Port Stephens to Jervis Bay would have four power plants, left-wing think-tank the Australia Institute says.

Victoria would have four more and South Australia three, including one at Port Adelaide, it suggests.

In all, the study names 17 likely sites for reactors, based on criteria such as proximity to seawater for cooling and access to the national electricity grid.

The institute also surveyed 1,200 Australians on their attitude towards having a reactor in their local area and found that 66 per cent were opposed.

A quarter of those surveyed, 25 per cent, were supportive and nine per cent undecided.

Fifty-five per cent were strongly opposed and just 10 per cent strongly in favour.

The study follows a determined push by the federal government towards the nuclear generation of electricity.

A government commissioned inquiry headed by Dr Ziggy Switkowski last year reported reactors would have to be positioned within tens of kilometres of the east coast national power grid.

It found that nuclear generation was attractive in the battle against greenhouse gas emissions and could be viable if there were to be a price on carbon.

That inquiry posed the scenario of 25 reactors producing a third of Australia's electricity needs by the year 2050.

The institute's director Dr Clive Hamilton said overseas experience showed that the siting of power plants is one of the most politically contentious aspects of the nuclear debate.

"The prime minister has called for a thorough and full-blooded debate about nuclear energy," Dr Hamilton said.

"We cannot have this debate without considering siting issues."

Report author Andrew Macintosh said the fact that nuclear energy attracted moderate levels of support at a general level but fierce opposition from local communities when concrete proposals were put forward suggested the presence of the not-in-my-backyard (NIMBY) phenomenon.

"That is, even if people do not oppose nuclear power plants at a general level, they often object to proposals to construct them in their local areas," he said.

The report raised the possibility that governments might compensate communities in a bid to placate local opposition to nuclear facilities.

Industry Minister Ian Macfarlane declined to comment on the report, saying the nuclear debate was too young to be talking about placement of reactors.

"It's too early to start speculating," a spokeswoman for Mr Macfarlane told AAP.

"He just wants to talk about it and start investigating it. Deciding on sites is something that's going to happen way down the track."

Labor's resources and energy spokesman Chris Evans said people in the communities identified by the report should expect a nuclear power plant in their area if Prime Minister John Howard's nuclear plans are successful.

Labor is opposed to a nuclear industry in Australia.

"Instead of talking up nuclear power John Howard should be encouraging an immediate increase in the use of renewable energy and the introduction of clean coal technologies," Senator Evans said.

"With Australia's existing energy resources, there is no reason for us to go down the nuclear path."

Labor's environment spokesman Peter Garrett said the report was further evidence Australia should not go nuclear.

"Australia needs to go on a low carbon diet, not a nuclear binge, and these figures show John Howard is increasingly out of step with Australians who are desperate for real action on climate change," he said.

Greens senator Kerry Nettle said the report unsurprisingly showed that populations close to the suggested sites did not want nuclear power plants.

"Instead of talking about 25 possible nuclear power plants, the prime minister should be looking for another 25 sites for major wind power stations and another 25 solar power stations," she said.

Read the article.

Read More......

Tuesday, January 23, 2007

America CAN Solve Global Warming


Landmark Study to Show: America CAN Solve Global Warming Without Nukes, Without Continued Dependence on Coal



Source: Greenpeace USA

WASHINGTON, Jan. 22 /PRNewswire-USNewswire/ -- On Wednesday, January
24, 2007 at 12 PM EST, Greenpeace USA will join with other climate and
energy advocates on a press conference call to release a landmark analysis
showing that the United States can address global warming, without relying
on nuclear power or so-called "clean coal" as some in the ongoing energy
debate claim.

The new study details a worldwide energy scenario where:

  • In the United States, nearly 80% of our electricity can be produced by renewable energy sources.
  • Carbon dioxide emissions can be reduced 50% globally and 72% in the U.S. without resorting to an increase in dangerous nuclear power or new coal technologies.
  • America's oil use can be cut over 50% by 2050 with much more efficient cars and trucks, potentially including new plug-in hybrids, increased use of biofuels, and greater reliance on electricity for transportation.


The study, commissioned from the internationally-respected German Aerospace Centre, shows that significantly increasing renewable energy and efficiency improvements alone can solve the global warming problem. It is the first study to fulfill the promise of Princeton Professors Stephen Pacala and Robert Socolow's "wedge" framework, by presenting an alternative scenario for reaching greenhouse gas stabilization.


  • Who: John Coequyt, Greenpeace USA;
  • Sven Teske, Greenpeace International
  • Scott Sklar, Sustainable Energy Coalition
  • What: Press conference call to unveil a new blueprint for solving global warming -- and correct the record on nukes and coal.
  • When: Wednesday
  • January 24, 2007
  • 12 PM EST
  • Call-In: 1-800-896-8445
  • Code: Greenpeace
  • Contact: Joel Finkelstein, +1-202-822-5200 ext. 279
  • Jane Kochersperger, +1-202-319-2493


Read the article.

Read More......

Saturday, January 20, 2007

Clean energy pact a 'diversion'

January 16, 2007 12:00
From http://www.news.com.au/

PRIME Minister John Howard's pact with China to use so-called clean coal technology was a typical diversion from the need to switch from coal to renewable energy, Greenpeace said today.

The environmental group said Mr Howard continued to ignore options that would deter industrialised economies from increasing greenhouse gas emissions.

Australia and China yesterday pledged to work together to develop cleaner energy alternatives following top level talks in the Philippines.

The pact coincided with a wider declaration on energy security made by 16 countries at the East Asia Summit (EAS) of regional leaders.

The declaration pledges a move towards nuclear and other alternative energy solutions, acknowledging the need for renewable energy development.

But Greenpeace spokesman Ben Pearson said China was already moving in that direction, having recently announced plans to invest 45.6 billion yuan ($7.41 billion) to more than triple wind power generation capacity by 2010 and aiming to reach a 15 per cent renewable energy target by 2020.

"This is the real solution to climate change and what Australia should be promoting," Mr Pearson said.

"The deal seems to involve no new financing and doesn't address the central problem that without a price on carbon, technologies such as geosequestration will never be commercially deployed.

"Moreover, it will be at least 10 years before we know if geosequestration even works, which is simply too late."

Mr Pearson said deep cuts were needed in greenhouse emissions of industrialised countries of at least 30 per cent by 2020 to avoid dangerous climate change.

"We may not even know if geosequestration will work by then," he said.

Read the article.

Read More......

Saturday, January 06, 2007

The Reality of Nuclear Power

Good evening. My name is David Lochbaum. I have been the Nuclear Safety Engineer for Union of Concerned Scientists for the past three years. Prior to joining UCS, I worked for over 17 years as a nuclear engineer in the nuclear industry. Between 1992 and 1995, I was a consultant to the New York Power Authority working primarily on their FitzPatrick nuclear power plant and some on their Indian Point Unit 3 facility.

I am going to speak a little bit about the history of nuclear power, but will focus more on its future. Many people have stated recently that the nuclear industry is at a crossroads because of electric utility deregulation. I personally do not subscribe to that theory because it implicitly implies either that we are all going in a big circle because we reach a crossroad every three or four months or that we are not moving at all and remain at the first crossroad we reached.

Workers at the Shippingport nuclear power plant outside Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania, flipped a switch in December 1957 to connect the plant's turbine-generator to the electrical grid. This marked the first time that a civilian utility company in the United States supplied electricity to its customers from nuclear power. In the subsequent four decades, nuclear power has generated billions of kilowatts of electricity, several thousand tons of highly radioactive waste, and immeasurable controversy.

Proponents claim that nuclear power is vital if the United States is to have energy independence and to combat global warming. Antinuclear activists claim that nuclear power plants are unacceptably risky and that nuclear waste is the wrong legacy for us to leave future generations.

This debate is what I call the politics of nuclear power. Three years of working inside the DC beltway have taught me one important lesson -- I don't want to work in politics, particularly the politics of nuclear power.

Read the article at Union of Concerned Scientists.

Read More......

Friday, January 05, 2007

Canberra to sell uranium to China

Friday, 5 January 2007



Australia will soon be able to export uranium to China, Australian Foreign Minister Alexander Downer has said.

The two countries signed an agreement earlier this year, which means the exports can begin in 30 days, he said.

Australia has 40% of the world's recoverable uranium, while China needs a huge amount of energy for its large population and rising economy.

Beijing is keen to increase its use of nuclear power, to cut down its dependence on fossil fuels.

Two bilateral nuclear treaties - the Australia-China Nuclear Transfer Agreement and the Nuclear Co-operation Agreement - were signed in April during Chinese Premier Wen Jiabao's visit to Canberra.

....

Read the Article.

Read More......