Showing posts with label clean coal. Show all posts
Showing posts with label clean coal. Show all posts

Saturday, June 14, 2008

Environment is secondary to private profits

May 22, 2008
From The AGE

Investing in renewable energy is being ignored to keep fossil fuels burning.

THE idea that coal-fired electricity generation can continue to be the major contributor to global electricity generation and the world can still restrict carbon dioxide emissions to a level constant with holding climate warming below 2 degrees is a fairytale, according to letter in the premier science journal Nature (published online, May 7, 2008).

Vaclav Smil, of the University of Manitoba, in Canada, makes a new point that is critical to the debate as it is being run by state and federal governments in Australia: "Carbon geosequestration is irresponsibly portrayed as an imminently useful large-scale option for solving the challenge. But to sequester just 25% of carbon dioxide emitted in 2005 by large stationary sources of the gas we would have to create a system whose annual throughput by volume would be slightly more than twice that of the world's crude-oil industry, an undertaking that would take many decades to accomplish."

And yet the Brumby and Rudd Governments persist in pouring money into geosequestration research at the expense of developing solar energy, among other renewable alternatives. Last month Premier John Brumby announced a $127 million package to develop "clean coal" including a $110 million fund to establish new large scale, pre-commercial carbon capture storage demonstration projects. These latest commitments will take Victoria's total clean coal investment to more than $244 million since 2002.

...

Read the article.

Read More......

Monday, April 28, 2008

Carbon capture and storage useless at preventing CO2 from Coal

19 April 2008
From New Scientist




Most coal today comes from opencast workings. Emissions, primarily of methane, CO2 and carbon monoxide, start as soon as the overburden above the coal seams is stripped away. Conservative estimates suggest that these gases alone account for about twice the emissions of the burning of the coal mined.


...

Read the article.

Read More......

Friday, June 29, 2007

Drop the fission line

Friday 29 June 2007
(URL for source to be found)
From Courier Mail, QLD, Australia

IMGP6918

Smart State ambassador Ian Lowe warns against a nuclear future

THE Queensland ALP conference this weekend offers an important forum for the Beattie Government to steer the state away from the risks of a radioactive future and towards sustainable energy options.

Prime Minister John Howard is actively promoting nuclear power as a belated answer to global climate change. Recent media reports suggest a wider federal nuclear agenda for Queensland that includes uranium enrichment and nuclear power.



Against this background it is important Premier Peter Beattie continues to keep the door firmly shut on uranium mining and the nuclear industry.

Uranium mining in Queensland would be economically short-sighted and environmentally disastrous. If we want to be the Smart State, we must use solar energy and other forms of renewables.

We should move towards better efficiency, turning our energy more effectively into the services we want. There are many more jobs and dollars in becoming a world leader in clean energy.

We have known for more than 20 years that burning coal, oil and gas is changing the global climate. Moves by the coal industry to clean up its act and reduce its pollution are welcome, but rushed pledges of taxpayer funding to assist this are not. The same money would do much more to curb greenhouse pollution if it were allocated to efficiency improvements and clean energy.

Some claim nuclear energy could help to slow climate change, but this is not a sensible solution. Even the Switkowski report, put together by a hand-picked group of pro-nuclear technocrats, did not make a convincing case.

The summary was optimistic, but the fine print of the report shows it would take about 15 years to build one nuclear power station if we started today, and the cost of electricity would more than double.

Even the most fanciful crash program, dotting 25 nuclear power stations all over the landscape, would only slow the growth in greenhouse pollution by less than 20 per cent. The science shows we need to make serious cuts, 60-90 per cent by 2050, not allow more increases.

Would uranium exports be an economic bonanza? No. The most optimistic forecast of the possible export income is about a third of our earnings from cheese exports. Uranium accounts for only about 1 per cent of our mineral exports and there is little prospect of it becoming a big earner.

What would be the cost of mining and exporting uranium? Huge volumes of radioactive mine tailings, depleted and degraded water resources and an increased risk from nuclear weapons and waste. We are still living with the legacy of the mines at Mary Kathleen and across the Northern Territory border at Rum Jungle.

Uranium mining needs large volumes of water -- not easy to find in Queensland at the moment -- and uses vast amounts of fossil energy, actually worsening greenhouse pollution.

Finally, as the Ranger uranium report said 30 years ago, uranium exports inevitably produce high-level radioactive waste that will have to be managed for hundreds of thousands of years and equally inevitably increase the risk of nuclear weapons.

Even if we say we have the best safeguards in the world and only export to the most responsible leaders, they won't be in power forever and can't control what others will do with the fissile material we sell.

We should learn the lesson of Iran. The world is now getting nervous about its possible nuclear developments. Thirty years ago, we were being urged to export uranium to Iran, and the US was trying to sell its nuclear technology to the Shah. Had that deal gone ahead, Iran would now have all it needs to build nuclear weapons.

The report A Bright Future showed we could get 25 per cent of our power from a mix of renewables by 2020. We should use solar hot water universally. Going that way would create literally thousands of real, skilled and permanent jobs in regional Australia.

Rather than facing a future of leaking tailings dams and increased pressure for nuclear reactors and waste dumps, Queensland can lead Australia and the world in sustainable and clean energy solutions.

The smart sunshine state is a much better option than being a toxic quarry.

Before last year's state election, the Premier stood firmly against the nuclear lobby and promised that the state would not support the mining or processing of uranium.

Beattie also resisted the silly suggestion that we should allow others to inflict on Queensland other stages of uranium processing, such as enrichment or dumping waste. As a Smart State ambassador, I strongly urge the Premier to resist those who want to drag us back into the Dark Age of uranium mining.

Ian Lowe is emeritus professor of science, technology and society at Griffith University and president of the Australian Conservation Foundation






...

Read the article.

Read More......

Tuesday, May 15, 2007

Beattie to lift coal royalties

May 09, 2007
From Courier Mail (QLD, AUST)

QUEENSLAND'S coal industry will be hit with increased royalties in next month's state budget to help curb climate change.
Premier Peter Beattie said today he was planning to increase coal royalties to force the industry into paying for clean coal technology research.

Speaking in New York, Mr Beattie said the increase would be for their own good because if the industry did not clean up coal it would not survive.

He said research was vital to cut greenhouse gas emissions, save the planet and ensure the long-term future of Queensland's powerhouse coal industry.

He angrily accused the state's coal companies of reneging on an agreement to provide $300 million for research into clean coal technologies.

...

Read the article.

Read More......

Wednesday, April 25, 2007

Risk ahead: overheating planet or nuclear disaster?

April 2007
From The Age (Aust)

IMGP4732.JPG

This post links to an interesting debate about Nuclear Energy in Australia. Climate Action Brisbane does not support Nuclear Energy for Australia. It may be relevant in other places in the world where they lack the alternatives, though in Australia we have many alternatives. Specifically, why we don't agree with Nuclear Energy for Australia for these reasons:


  • we have enormous amounts of sunshine and wind (all across the country - this distribution helps with baseload requirements),
  • we don't have much spare water which is required for Nuclear Energy
  • it would take a long time to have a nuclear reactor up and running in Australia - time we don't have with the Climate Crisis hanging over our heads
  • the cost to build a reactor is enourmous
  • the cost to decomission a reactor is many times bigger though we don't fully know because this has not been done anywhere in the world
  • Uranium mining takes enormous amounts of energy and disturbs the carbon locked up in the ground, releasing it into the atmosphere
  • Transporting the ore takes considerable energy
  • Processing Uranium takes enormous amounts of energy, and as the amount of high-grade Uranium reduces, the cost to process less-pure forms requires more and more energy
  • Nuclear proliferation is a real posssibility when Nuclear Energy and reactors are considered the norm along with all the radioactive wastes they produce
  • A de-centralised model of energy generation is much more efficient and will produce far more jobs over a wide area rather than concentrated in one area. By spreading out our energy production we lessen the damage caused by a malfunction at any big centralised energy production centers (think terrorists here). Decentralised energy means that people are more in touch with where their energy comes from and will assist them to understand conservation and being more lean. (See "There is no shortage of energy" in ZMag: Global Warming: Limits of Solar and Wind Power)
  • the world is moving away from Nuclear Energy - Germany is switching away from nuclear to solar for example
  • did I mention that Australia has abundant solar and wind energy available to be tapped.
  • because Nuclear and Clean Coal is what big business wants and is just wrong. These people don't get it. We have to change how we view the world. But no this statement does not mean we will be travelling around by horse and cart (for starters this is a very inefficient form of transport). It means that we will be leading leaner lives. It means that we will grow and eat more food locally. It means that we will have a greater use of decentralised water gathering (rainwater tanks, gray water systems) and more decentralised energy producing centers. It means that we must learn to accept other people. It means that there will be less need for agression, war and the military in general.


Read the article.

Read More......

Sunday, March 04, 2007

Flannery: Clean coal may not be viable

February 14, 2007
From Sydney Mornign Hearald (Aust)

Australian of the Year and leading scientist Dr Tim Flannery has questioned the viability of clean coal technology, saying it may be made redundant by cheaper and greener energy resources.


Dr Flannery told the Australian Workers Union (AWU) biannual meeting on the Gold Coast there was a need to switch to low emission energy sources.

He was greeted with hearty applause from the 200 delegates - something which surprised the scientist who has been accused in the media of wanting to shut down the nation's coal industry.

He dismissed the claims as entirely untrue but admitted he had some reservations about the viability of clean coal technology, which is Queensland Premier Peter Beattie's preferred option to reduce gas emissions.

He said Australia did not possess the right geological conditions to support the clean coal process, which injected carbon dioxide emissions into the ground rather than releasing them into the atmosphere.

"Globally there has got to be some areas where clean coal will work out, so I think there will always be a coal export industry (for Australia)," he said.

"Locally in Australia because of particular geological issues and because of the competition from cleaner and cheaper energy alternatives, I'm not 100 per cent sure clean coal is going to work out for our domestic market."

Australian of the Year and leading scientist Dr Tim Flannery has questioned the viability of clean coal technology, saying it may be made redundant by cheaper and greener energy resources.

Dr Flannery told the Australian Workers Union (AWU) biannual meeting on the Gold Coast there was a need to switch to low emission energy sources.

He was greeted with hearty applause from the 200 delegates - something which surprised the scientist who has been accused in the media of wanting to shut down the nation's coal industry.

He dismissed the claims as entirely untrue but admitted he had some reservations about the viability of clean coal technology, which is Queensland Premier Peter Beattie's preferred option to reduce gas emissions.

He said Australia did not possess the right geological conditions to support the clean coal process, which injected carbon dioxide emissions into the ground rather than releasing them into the atmosphere.

"Globally there has got to be some areas where clean coal will work out, so I think there will always be a coal export industry (for Australia)," he said.

"Locally in Australia because of particular geological issues and because of the competition from cleaner and cheaper energy alternatives, I'm not 100 per cent sure clean coal is going to work out for our domestic market."

However, Dr Flannery said Australia possessed the right conditions to make geothermal technology, using underground energy to produce electricity, while solar power was becoming increasingly viable.

The cost of geothermal-produced electricity would be similar to that of electricity produced by coal-fired power stations, Dr Flannery said, but he dismissed claims of a cost blow-out linked to alternative energy.

Dr Flannery agreed with the sentiments of British scientist Dr David King that climate change was a bigger global threat than terrorism and called on the Australian government to act immediately.

"They need to be getting a war footing using some of the budget surplus to start the building infrastructure to get on the transition path to lower emissions energy as soon as possible," Dr Flannery said.

"Economists may tell you that it will take 20 years but when there is a war on you get it done in a few years so we need to act quickly."


Read the article.

Read More......

Saturday, February 10, 2007

Brown backs eventual coal export ban

February 09, 2007
From News.com.

GREENS leader Bob Brown today backed a ban on coal exports and coal-fired power generation in Australia to be adopted over a three-year period.

Senator Brown agreed the move would cause massive disruption but said extreme measures were needed to respond to climate change.

The proposal follows comments by Australian of the Year Professor Tim Flannery, who said the social licence of coal was rapidly being withdrawn globally because of its contribution to greenhouse gas emissions.

Senator Brown said Australia had to move in that direction.

"To suddenly ban coal exports would be massively dislocating but we have got to do it and we have to do it within a period of a government. That should be the sort of aim we are looking at," he said on ABC radio.

"This is where politicians will panic. But we are exporting to the rest of the world what is effectively a deadly threat to the whole planet and our children."

Coal is Australia's largest export, earning more than $25 billion a year.

Senator Brown said the Greens saw it as politically unacceptable to have a phase-out over 30 years which would wipe out the lifestyle, economy and jobs of future generations.

He said clean coal technology was still at least a decade away and the challenge to the big parties was whether they would wait up to three decades before taking proper action.

"The Greens are talking about intervening on the market. The big parties won't and so are therefore saying let this country and the rest of the planet go to perdition because we won't take action," he said.

"We are a rich and wealthy country. We can look after the coal miners and we can replace their fortunes with a much more job-productive industry."

Senator Brown said he was proposing a reduction of coal exports and replacing them with exports of renewable energy.

He said Australia had fantastic solar energy research which could save the planet but which was being purchased by foreign companies.

"I am talking about having a plan with one term of government for the phasing-out of coal," he said.
"We do need extreme measures, compared to what has happened in the past."

"This Government has let the country down. This Government has become a menace to the future of our children."

Read the article.

Read More......

flannery: 'No justification' for coal exports

February 08, 2007
From News.com (Aust).


AUSTRALIA can no longer justify its coal exports in the face of global warming fuelled by burning the commodity, Australian of the Year Tim Flannery said.

The Federal Government is counting on Australian-made clean coal technology being used to clean up coal-fired power stations in China and India.

With hundreds of coal-fired power stations due to be commissioned in developing nations in the coming years, the government has committed $6 million to help China work out how it can use new low-emission technology in their existing power stations.

But Professor Flannery said exporting coal could no longer be considered to be in Australia's national interest.

"That time has already come and the social licence of coal to operate is rapidly being withdrawn globally, and no government can protect an industry from that sort of thing occurring," he told ABC TV's Lateline program.

"We've seen it with asbestos, we'll see it with coal.

"We have to deal with that issue if we want a stable climate."

Prime Minister John Howard this week ruled out regulating Australia's lucrative coal exports to ensure it was only used in power stations employing cleaner technology, saying it would be a knee-jerk response that would damage the economy.

The Government should not bank on cleaner coal technology to solve the problem, Prof Flannery said.

"The technology is going to be too small and come too late to fix the problem," he said.

"The problem has grown too big now to be fixed. We need real investment from Government, real sacrifice at the moment for a better future."

Mr Howard also has said he feared that if China stopped using Australian coal the country would use a dirtier domestic product and make the situation worse.

Prof Flannery said that argument was "a false equation".

"The Europeans are already talking about tariffs, carbon-based tariffs," he said.

"As the situation unfolds and matters get more critical, the world is not going to allow people to pollute our common atmosphere.

"The social licence to operate those old polluting technologies would be withdrawn."

The Howard Government had made matters worse for itself by failing to ratify the Kyoto pact which dealt with the unwanted consequences of the coal trade, Prof Flannery said.

"If we'd done that 10 years ago we may have lessened the damage that was being done and we may have been on a trajectory that was healing the planet," he said.

"We didn't do that, so now the medicine we have to take has to be more radical."

Read the article.

Also see



Read More......

Tuesday, February 06, 2007

Greenpeace Proposes an Energy Revolution

6th Feb 2007
From eMagazine.

...

Bush’s call for a zero emission coal-fired plant is an untested idea. “Carbon capture and storage [CCS] or so-called ‘clean coal’ is not a proven technology,” says Sven Teske of Greenpeace International. “There is not a single commercial-scale power plant right now on the grid. We’ve seen through our analysis that wind turbines in some areas are competitive with new coal power plants already, or will be in the next five years.” In terms of nuclear power, Teske says, “Besides all the dangers...it is just too slow. It takes about 10 years to build one. The only European new reactor under construction is in Finland. One year under construction and already it’s one year behind schedule.”

Still, coal companies have plans for more than 100 new coal-burning power plants to be built in the U.S. to meet energy needs. Seventeen of those would be built in Bush’s home state, Texas, where Governor Rick Perry has attempted to speed the process through executive order. And they aren’t of the expensive “clean coal” variety. A National Public Radio story on the Texas coal plants says, “The new power plants in Texas will emit the equivalent of 19 million automobiles’ worth of carbon dioxide every year. When all the new plants are up and running, Texas will send nearly as much carbon dioxide up its stacks as California, New York and Florida combined.” Following suit, more than 700 additional coal plants are scheduled for China and India by 2012.

The U.S. is known as the “Saudi Arabia of coal,” with enough supply to last hundreds of years, and China has a similar coal surplus. Having rejected the Kyoto Protocol, which aimed to cut greenhouse gas emissions, the Bush Administration favors voluntary carbon reductions and supporting technologies that capture carbon dioxide (CO2) emissions before they are released into the atmosphere. But that technology is expensive and the incentive that might come from federal mandate isn’t there.

...

Read the article.

Read More......

Thursday, February 01, 2007

Coastal sites flagged for nuke reactors

Tuesday Jan 30 22:35 AEDT
From http://news.ninemsn.com.au

Nuclear reactors are likely to be spaced out along the Australian coast from Townsville in Queensland to Port Augusta in South Australia under a nuclear-powered future, a new study says.

Queensland would have six reactors and the coast around Sydney from Port Stephens to Jervis Bay would have four power plants, left-wing think-tank the Australia Institute says.

Victoria would have four more and South Australia three, including one at Port Adelaide, it suggests.

In all, the study names 17 likely sites for reactors, based on criteria such as proximity to seawater for cooling and access to the national electricity grid.

The institute also surveyed 1,200 Australians on their attitude towards having a reactor in their local area and found that 66 per cent were opposed.

A quarter of those surveyed, 25 per cent, were supportive and nine per cent undecided.

Fifty-five per cent were strongly opposed and just 10 per cent strongly in favour.

The study follows a determined push by the federal government towards the nuclear generation of electricity.

A government commissioned inquiry headed by Dr Ziggy Switkowski last year reported reactors would have to be positioned within tens of kilometres of the east coast national power grid.

It found that nuclear generation was attractive in the battle against greenhouse gas emissions and could be viable if there were to be a price on carbon.

That inquiry posed the scenario of 25 reactors producing a third of Australia's electricity needs by the year 2050.

The institute's director Dr Clive Hamilton said overseas experience showed that the siting of power plants is one of the most politically contentious aspects of the nuclear debate.

"The prime minister has called for a thorough and full-blooded debate about nuclear energy," Dr Hamilton said.

"We cannot have this debate without considering siting issues."

Report author Andrew Macintosh said the fact that nuclear energy attracted moderate levels of support at a general level but fierce opposition from local communities when concrete proposals were put forward suggested the presence of the not-in-my-backyard (NIMBY) phenomenon.

"That is, even if people do not oppose nuclear power plants at a general level, they often object to proposals to construct them in their local areas," he said.

The report raised the possibility that governments might compensate communities in a bid to placate local opposition to nuclear facilities.

Industry Minister Ian Macfarlane declined to comment on the report, saying the nuclear debate was too young to be talking about placement of reactors.

"It's too early to start speculating," a spokeswoman for Mr Macfarlane told AAP.

"He just wants to talk about it and start investigating it. Deciding on sites is something that's going to happen way down the track."

Labor's resources and energy spokesman Chris Evans said people in the communities identified by the report should expect a nuclear power plant in their area if Prime Minister John Howard's nuclear plans are successful.

Labor is opposed to a nuclear industry in Australia.

"Instead of talking up nuclear power John Howard should be encouraging an immediate increase in the use of renewable energy and the introduction of clean coal technologies," Senator Evans said.

"With Australia's existing energy resources, there is no reason for us to go down the nuclear path."

Labor's environment spokesman Peter Garrett said the report was further evidence Australia should not go nuclear.

"Australia needs to go on a low carbon diet, not a nuclear binge, and these figures show John Howard is increasingly out of step with Australians who are desperate for real action on climate change," he said.

Greens senator Kerry Nettle said the report unsurprisingly showed that populations close to the suggested sites did not want nuclear power plants.

"Instead of talking about 25 possible nuclear power plants, the prime minister should be looking for another 25 sites for major wind power stations and another 25 solar power stations," she said.

Read the article.

Read More......

Tuesday, January 23, 2007

America CAN Solve Global Warming


Landmark Study to Show: America CAN Solve Global Warming Without Nukes, Without Continued Dependence on Coal



Source: Greenpeace USA

WASHINGTON, Jan. 22 /PRNewswire-USNewswire/ -- On Wednesday, January
24, 2007 at 12 PM EST, Greenpeace USA will join with other climate and
energy advocates on a press conference call to release a landmark analysis
showing that the United States can address global warming, without relying
on nuclear power or so-called "clean coal" as some in the ongoing energy
debate claim.

The new study details a worldwide energy scenario where:

  • In the United States, nearly 80% of our electricity can be produced by renewable energy sources.
  • Carbon dioxide emissions can be reduced 50% globally and 72% in the U.S. without resorting to an increase in dangerous nuclear power or new coal technologies.
  • America's oil use can be cut over 50% by 2050 with much more efficient cars and trucks, potentially including new plug-in hybrids, increased use of biofuels, and greater reliance on electricity for transportation.


The study, commissioned from the internationally-respected German Aerospace Centre, shows that significantly increasing renewable energy and efficiency improvements alone can solve the global warming problem. It is the first study to fulfill the promise of Princeton Professors Stephen Pacala and Robert Socolow's "wedge" framework, by presenting an alternative scenario for reaching greenhouse gas stabilization.


  • Who: John Coequyt, Greenpeace USA;
  • Sven Teske, Greenpeace International
  • Scott Sklar, Sustainable Energy Coalition
  • What: Press conference call to unveil a new blueprint for solving global warming -- and correct the record on nukes and coal.
  • When: Wednesday
  • January 24, 2007
  • 12 PM EST
  • Call-In: 1-800-896-8445
  • Code: Greenpeace
  • Contact: Joel Finkelstein, +1-202-822-5200 ext. 279
  • Jane Kochersperger, +1-202-319-2493


Read the article.

Read More......

Saturday, January 20, 2007

Clean energy pact a 'diversion'

January 16, 2007 12:00
From http://www.news.com.au/

PRIME Minister John Howard's pact with China to use so-called clean coal technology was a typical diversion from the need to switch from coal to renewable energy, Greenpeace said today.

The environmental group said Mr Howard continued to ignore options that would deter industrialised economies from increasing greenhouse gas emissions.

Australia and China yesterday pledged to work together to develop cleaner energy alternatives following top level talks in the Philippines.

The pact coincided with a wider declaration on energy security made by 16 countries at the East Asia Summit (EAS) of regional leaders.

The declaration pledges a move towards nuclear and other alternative energy solutions, acknowledging the need for renewable energy development.

But Greenpeace spokesman Ben Pearson said China was already moving in that direction, having recently announced plans to invest 45.6 billion yuan ($7.41 billion) to more than triple wind power generation capacity by 2010 and aiming to reach a 15 per cent renewable energy target by 2020.

"This is the real solution to climate change and what Australia should be promoting," Mr Pearson said.

"The deal seems to involve no new financing and doesn't address the central problem that without a price on carbon, technologies such as geosequestration will never be commercially deployed.

"Moreover, it will be at least 10 years before we know if geosequestration even works, which is simply too late."

Mr Pearson said deep cuts were needed in greenhouse emissions of industrialised countries of at least 30 per cent by 2020 to avoid dangerous climate change.

"We may not even know if geosequestration will work by then," he said.

Read the article.

Read More......