Showing posts with label john howard. Show all posts
Showing posts with label john howard. Show all posts

Sunday, November 04, 2007

Dr Guy Pearse on Howard the denier and destructor

27th Oct 07


From Kim Bax - Mum and Environment compaigner.

Dr Guy Pearce, author of HIGH & DRY speaks at the I2th annual Sunshine Coast Environment Awards


27th Oct 07

Howard tells us:

  • We’re told we will meet our Kyoto target, but not that it is an emissions increase target which, thanks mainly to land clearing cuts, enables us to increase emissions 27%;
  • We’re told there’s $3.5 billion being spent on climate change but not that, on an annual basis, twice as much is being spent on government advertising; more than a million dollars a day. And, on day one of this election campaign he spent ten times as much as his entire climate change budget in just one round of tax cuts.
  • We’re told banning incandescent light bulbs leads the world but just how world-leading is it given we need over 800 measures on that scale to cut our projected emissions in half by mid century?;
  • We’re told Australia is being prepared for the impacts of climate change but not that eleven times as much is being spent on the war in Iraq as on Howard’s entire greenhouse adaptation program?;
  • The Prime Minister says we’re on track to be an energy superpower but on his watch Australia actually started paying more for energy imports than we make from energy exports;
  • We’re told uranium and LNG are saving the global climate but this looks decidedly shaky when you factor in the far greater emissions caused by our coal exports which are projected to double by 2030;
  • We hear the Asia Pacific Partnership is a superior alternative to the Kyoto Protocol, but it rings hollow when you consider the AP6 requires no emission cuts of any country this century;
  • We’re told clean coal is just around the corner but not that coal-fired electricity providers reckon they don’t expect it to be commercially viable on any meaningful scale until at least 2020?
  • We’re told nuclear is the clean green saviour but not that John Howard’s own inquiry into its potential, found that even with a dozen nuclear power stations our emissions would still be 90% above I990 levels by 2050?




I joined the Liberal Party in I989, I remain a member and I never imagined campaigning for the defeat of my own party. But a continuation of John Howard’s response to climate change is also unimaginable and it’s something I can’t support. My politics haven’t changed a great deal since I989 but the Liberal Party’s greenhouse policy sure has.

In I990, the Liberal Party led by Andrew Peacock had a policy to reduce Australia’s greenhouse pollution by at least 20% by the year 2000. It was promising bigger cuts sooner than the Labor Party and was proud of the fact that it embraced national emission reduction targets first. That 20% emission reduction target was a commitment John Hewson retained as leader of the party in the early I990s. John Howard has taken a very different and dangerous direction. But before I get into that, a bit about my background.

I spent most of my career either working in or around the Liberal Party. Since about I994, I’ve also been immersed in environment policy, especially climate change; writing speeches for the first Howard government Environment minister, consulting to the Australian Greenhouse Office, lobbying for various industries, and as a PhD researcher.

With a political career in mind I hoped these were good career steps; environment policy specialists are thin on the ground in Liberal ranks. Instead, I found myself unable to ignore my party’s shifting response to climate change, the industry lobbying behind that push and the way we were deceiving the public about the consequences.

Much of this was revealed through my PhD research the conclusions of which were very unwelcome to me as a Liberal Party member. I raised my concerns with various senior Howard government people but to no avail and ultimately I made the fateful decision that it was unethical to self-sensor my research for political reasons.

Plan A, right up until mid 2005, had been to move my young family back to Queensland and more specifically to the Sunshine Coast hinterland, where I had the strong support of senior Queensland Liberals to run for federal parliament. But Plan A was finished as soon as I decided against self-censoring my PhD. In early 2006, some of my findings were aired on the Greenhouse Mafia episode of Four Corners. From then on, it was clear my party was complicit rather than oblivious. As expected, the shutters came down on me and any prospect of a political career.

So I decided to write High & Dry. If the party didn’t want to know that our greenhouse policy was being high-jacked, let alone the implications, then the whole story of how John Howard came to confuse the national interest with polluter interests needed telling.

Of course, if you believe John Howard, it’s a story that needs no telling because Australia ‘leads the world on climate change.’ But behind the smokescreen, the reality is very different:


  • We’re told we will meet our Kyoto target, but not that it is an emissions increase target which, thanks mainly to land clearing cuts, enables us to increase emissions 27%;
  • We’re told there’s $3.5 billion being spent on climate change but not that, on an annual basis, twice as much is being spent on government advertising; more than a million dollars a day. And, on day one of this election campaign he spent ten times as much as his entire climate change budget in just one round of tax cuts.
  • We’re told banning incandescent light bulbs leads the world but just how world-leading is it given we need over 800 measures on that scale to cut our projected emissions in half by mid century?;
  • We’re told Australia is being prepared for the impacts of climate change but not that eleven times as much is being spent on the war in Iraq as on Howard’s entire greenhouse adaptation program?;
  • The Prime Minister says we’re on track to be an energy superpower but on his watch Australia actually started paying more for energy imports than we make from energy exports;
  • We’re told uranium and LNG are saving the global climate but this looks decidedly shaky when you factor in the far greater emissions caused by our coal exports which are projected to double by 2030;
  • We hear the Asia Pacific Partnership is a superior alternative to the Kyoto Protocol, but it rings hollow when you consider the AP6 requires no emission cuts of any country this century;
  • We’re told clean coal is just around the corner but not that coal-fired electricity providers reckon they don’t expect it to be commercially viable on any meaningful scale until at least 2020?
  • We’re told nuclear is the clean green saviour but not that John Howard’s own inquiry into its potential, found that even with a dozen nuclear power stations our emissions would still be 90% above I990 levels by 2050?


And we’re told renewable energy can’t replace baseload power when it is already doing that elsewhere in the world.

Once you strip away the spin, the truth emerges; the cumulative impact of Howard’s policies after eleven years is that our emissions are on track to rise 70% by mid century. While he loudly claims that by slowing emissions growth he is doing the equivalent of taking fourteen million cars off our roads, the emissions growth he is allowing have us on track to add the equivalent of at least seventy million cars by 2050.

It’s been all about moving money and people between the carbon lobby and Howard’s circle of trust. When you look at who funds the economic advice produced by the Australian Bureau of Agriculture and Resource Economics (ABARE) you find our worst polluting industries bought their way onto committees overseeing some of this as recently as last year. Some of the same industries pay hundreds of thousands to hire ABARE (not based on independent assumptions but on the paying client’s own assumptions), some even donate money to ABARE’s overall research program, all of which helps ABARE meet an external funding requirement.

Look behind the scientific advice produced by sections of the CSIRO, and the CRSs who have been in John Howard’s ear on clean coal and you find polluter funding.

Look at who funds the think tanks and front groups denying the science and warning of doomsday, were we to cut emissions, and you find the carbon lobby writing more big checks. And it’s the same with the hired guns; the economists, lobbyists and other policy gurus who have had the ear of the Prime Minister.

Look at who funds he Liberal Party itself and you find millions of dollars from the same polluter interests, being channeled from our worst greenhouse polluters, much of it through the back and side doors to avoid public scrutiny. And the career paths follow a similar trail as the money. A constant rotation of personnel between carbon intensive industry, federal bureaucracy and the Liberal Party builds careers for quarry visionaries and ensures they have the inside running. And it has thoroughly corrupted my party’s response to climate change.

Taking care of much of this day to day is a small group of Canberra based lobbyists working together under the banner of the Australian Industry Greenhouse Network- otherwise known as the ’greenhouse mafia’.

We’re in this position because John Howard was sold what I call a ‘quarry vision’ of Australia’s future. A flawed belief that cheap fossil fuel and the mining, metals and fossil energy sectors are not just the key to our current prosperity but the key to our economic future and protecting them at all costs is the underlying goal of our greenhouse policy.

Meanwhile as is so apparent in a place like the Sunshine Coast, 90% of GDP, and 95% of jobs in our economy are not generated by these ‘quarry industries’. John Howard might talk up carbon capture as the way to clean up coal but it is he who has been captured by the carbon lobby and their quarry vision for Australia.

So how did they sell that vision to John Howard? To find out, we need to go inside John Howard’s Greenhouse policy ’circle of trust’, a concept many of you will be familiar with from the movie Meet the Fockers. It is only a shame Robert De Niro was not there with the polygraph in this case too.
When you look closely at the Howard government’s greenhouse policy - how it evolved, where the arguments originate - you find that he has consistently listened to relatively few sources. They are key political allies inside the Liberal Party; the Bush administration; a few government departments and a few agencies like ABARE; Australian Nuclear Science and Technology Organisation(ANSTO), the chief scientist, and sections of CSIRO focused on clean coal technology.

He’s listened to; a small group of conservative commentators; a few conservative think’ tanks; the work of a small group of innocuous sounding lobbyists and economists; firms like ACIL Tasman, CRA International, and ITS Global. He’s heard the top end of town mainly through an equally innocuous sounding lobby group called the AustralianIndustry Greenhouse Network.

When you listen closely to these sources, you hear a complementary mix of denial and delay. Deny the scientific basis for action and/or delay emission cuts by Australia. What I found over a decade of work was that denial and delay were two sides of the same coin and the coin was coming from the same source as most of the pollution.

The AIGN represents about a dozen industry associations and a similar number of multinationals, mostly foreign owned. They account for Australia’s most carbon intensive industries: Coal, oil, aluminium, steel, cement, carmakers, and a few others.

In my PhD research I interviewed over a dozen senior past and present AIGN executives. They referred to themselves as the ‘greenhouse mafia’ and it was soon clear why. They run the country’s greenhouse policy remotely on behalf of the few industries they represent. They explained, in great detail, how they fixed the game time and again.

They said they’reverse-managed’the greenhouse ministerial committee; to stop emissions trading, to prevent Australia ratifying Kyoto, to avoid greenhouse emissions triggering federal environmental approval processes and to water down the Mandatory Renewable Energy Target.

They told how they reverse managed the broader business community into towing the line of the biggest polluters and how they got included in Australia’s official delegation to international greenhouse negotiations. They even told, on tape, how they were able to get inside the bureaucracy and help write cabinet submissions and ministerial briefings and costings on greenhouse policy.

Before they joined the greenhouse mafia, most of the lobbyists were once Branch Heads, Assistant Secretaries or Ministerial Advisers in the industry portfolio. Their former underlings now ran the relevant sections of the bureaucracy. So, if the public servant looked forward to a well paid industry job later on, it made good sense to go along with the greenhouse mafia bosses.

This dynamic operates right across Howard’s trusted circle; a blurred line between public, private and partisan; a shared belief that the interests of the nation are the same as the interests of carbon intensive industries.

It’s tempting perhaps to think that the PM is a victim in all of this, that he has been unwittingly captured by nefarious vested interests. That was my hope for quite a while. However, the evidence suggests otherwise. John Howard’s greenhouse scepticism goes way back. He said of the UN climate change convention: "We should never have got on this particular truck in Rio in the first place."

Since about I999 Howard started to take control of greenhouse policy because polluters felt his environment ministers were too green. He took over as chairman of the Cabinet committee overseeing greenhouse policy, unilaterally announced Australia would not ratify Kyoto, blocked emissions trading in cabinet twice - once effectively rolling half a dozen of his ministers after consulting a group of high polluting industry executives hand-picked by him. And his 2004 Energy White Paper ticked off the carbon lobby’s entire list.

He let a greenhouse sceptic run his backbench environment committee. He intervened in preselections to keep greenhouse sceptics in parliament. He appointed a coal industry executive as chief scientist, even allowing him to keep working three days a week at Rio Tinto. He hired the same consultants as the carbon lobby to advise him on greenhouse without any open tender and, when he decided emissions trading was unavoidable, he let our Australia’s worst polluting industries design one to their liking, even seconding the head of the AIGN to his department.

Time and again, he goes out of his way to give Australia’s ‘carbon club’ their way.

And one of the real problems has been the people around John Howard.

  • His Finance minister is an avowed sceptic and has publicly defended mining industry executives who have denied the science.
  • His Industry minister is another sceptic. When AI Gore visited Australia in 2006, this minister dismissed Gore’s documentary as incorrect and as nothing more than entertainment.
  • His Forestry minister is on record saying weeds are much more serious than the problem climate change may or may not be.
  • The Foreign minister hired as his speechwriter a conservative columnist who still denies humans have anything to do with climate change.
  • His Vocational Education minister, reckons the science is unproven, the warming we’re seeing mostly natural. He dismisses climate change as a trendy cause for lefties, seized since the fall of communism.
  • His Tourism minister who seriously suggested shade cloth as a way to save the Barrier Reef from climate change now says wind power is a fraud that belongs in the northern hemisphere, not here.


The Chair of Howard’s environment policy Committee launched a document at Parliament House saying climate change is a ‘scam’ and even suggesting those in charge of the (Intergovernmental Panel on climets Change (IPCC) should be jailed, presumably along with the Nobel Peace Prizes they now share with AI Gore.

So, many of Howard’s closest colleagues don’t believe climate change is a real problem caused mainly by humanity and this response has gone totally unchallenged.

The challenge for John Howard of late has been what to do now that the public has switched on to climate change. He’s had to feign a conversion on climate change while still planning to delay emission cuts in Australia. Let’s run through what’s being hatched right now:

First, he’s trying to appear to embrace the idea of emissions reduction targets when in fact he’s backing three types of target that are distant cousins at best:


  1. emission increase targets like Australia’s Kyoto target which is non-binding because Australia hasn’t ratified;

  2. regional or global reduction targets that are non-binding; and

  3. targets which will be met anyway, as with the ‘business as usual’ improvements in energy intensity and forest cover which were dressed up as targets in the APEC Sydney Declaration.


Next, Howard is shifting the focus onto individuals with the’Climate Clever’campaign- which really ought to be called ‘Climate Conned.’ The more people can be coaxed into obsessing with their own emissions, the less likely they are to realise that emissions would rise 60% by mid century even if Australians cut residential emissions to zero; or that one million of us could take our cars off the road tomorrow and just one new aluminium smelter would wipe out the emissions saved.

Third, Howard’s giving the appearance of backing renewable energy without doing so. He’s merely bundled up the existing renewable energy mandates; the federal one he refused to increase and the state ones he opposed. Then he’s lumped in existing renewable capacity and broadened the eligibility to make clean coal and nuclear qualify. This is now dressed up as a grand I5% renewable energy target when in fact it’s basically business as usual.

Fourth, he’s giving the appearance of embracing emissions trading but saying nothing about the strength of the scheme. Four years before it starts, he’s calling his ETS the ‘best in the world’ but won’t provide any of the crucial details which will determine whether the scheme will actually result in deep cuts in Australia’s emissions.

He’ll say now that pensioners will be compensated for the impact of a carbon price on energy bills but he’s hiding the reason why pensioners will need compensation and that is that he has allowed our worst polluting industries to carve themselves from the scheme’s impact, which according to ABARE roughly doubles the burden of a carbon price on the rest of the community.

So we have an audacious plan to dress up business as usual as ‘leading the world’ and so keen are many in the media to write the ‘Howard back flip on climate change’ story that most of them have bought it.

So, what about Kevin Rudd and the Labor Party? Are they going to be any better than John Howard and the Coalition? Well, Labor has committed to some of the key steps Australia needs to take to have an effective response to climate change.

They have committed to long term emissions reduction target; a 60% reduction in Australia’s emissions by 2050; Immediate ratification of the Kyoto Protocol; and a substantial increase in the Mandatory Renewable Energy Target.

They’ll establish an Emissions Trading Scheme (ETS) and crucially, one which will be consistent with deep cuts in Australia’s emissions by mid-century (this is important because Howard has not tied his scheme to any emissions reduction target). Labor has also committed to phasing out new electric hot water systems from 20I0.

And they have also commissioned Ross Garnaut to conduct the first ever full investigation of the economics of climate change; finally costing the impacts of climate change, and incorporating the benefits of emissions reduction, not just the costs. So there are some good signs from Labor.

But there are also some areas of concern: The lack of detail about the strength of the ETS and the loopholes it may allow big polluters; the lack of a medium term emissions target; the lack of detail on how much they plan to increase the renewable energy mandate; and no major attention yet to adaptation. As well the ALP has its own sceptics and some of its state governments have been vulnerable to the same sort of carbon capture we have seen with John Howard.

With all that in mind, I’m cautiously optimistic about a Rudd government when it comes to climate change but I’ll be even more optimistic if the Greens hold the balance of power in the Senate to keep them on track. Whatever happens, this issue won’t be fixed on election day no matter what the result.

So what has to be done to get us back on track? Well, the first thing is to embrace the idea that Australia has to do to its own emissions what it expects of the rest of the world. We have to lead by example.

So we need to abandon the idea that there is some way around binding emissions reduction targets and timetables. We need a long term emissions reduction target consistent with what is required globally and we need a short-medium term target or target range, knowing that once we ratify Kyoto we will negotiate a new binding target covering the next commitment period.

Then we need to establish an emissions trading scheme that sets a price on emissions sufficient to stay on track with these targets and doesn’t carve out our worst polluting industries.

This needs to be complemented with additional measures for the simple reason that emissions trading is not a fix-all. To ensure that emission cuts are not merely outsourced to other parts of the world, we need a much stronger Renewable Energy mandate and energy efficiency regulation in various sectors, especially transport.

Unless we do this we may find we are merely a donor to the global clean energy transition, rather than part of it. While we’re at it, we need a moratorium on new coal fired power stations and we need to start rethinking our involvement in coal mining because this is an industry which could end up losing the race to become a commercially viable low emissions technology in time and we need to be ready for that possibility as a country.

This all needs to be complemented with a nationally led adaptation policy so that the nation can start preparing for the huge impacts of climate change-some of which are inevitable.

And we shouldn’t fall for the myth that doing the right thing will wreck the economy. Few people understand that when John Howard tells us that if we cut our emissions in half it would cut GDP by I0%, what he actually means is that, according to ABARE’s own projections, in 2050 it would be 246% higher than today rather than 28I % higher. Similarly when Howard says that real wages would be cut bys 20%, what he means is that they would only be 8I % higher.

We should also keep in mind that the path we are on, 70% higher emissions by mid century, is simply not a long term viable option so it’s not a very useful point of comparison.

So where does this leave Australians? What can they do. Well here are three suggestions on how you can be Climate Clever without being Climate Conned into ignoring the big picture.


  1. Focus on cutting emissions in ways that save money: I don’t buy the idea that we need to cut back on our quality of life to cut emissions. There is too much evidence to the contrary. If you take up just some of the easy options then spend a few dollars a week on I00% renewable energy, you can easily do at the household level what is required globally and be financially better off. If you go to the long version of this presentation on my website you’ll see lots of specific suggestions;

  2. Start your own adaptation planning: Just because government is abrogating its responsibility doesn’t mean we should too and we need to realize that the impacts of climate change affect all sorts of equations in our own lives from where we live to what careers we choose. Once again, on my website and in the book you’ll find more suggestions on what we can do as individuals.

  3. Use your political clout: Our own efforts are wasted unless we also force change at the political and corporate levels. We have to vote on this issue and judge political parties on whether the cumulative effect of their policy is to cut Australia’s emissions in line with the deep cuts required globally; and whether they are preparing Australia for the inevitable impacts of climate change.
    And don’t think your political clout is confined to the ballot box or to this election. We need to keep pushing by joining and supporting environmental organizations at all levels, writing to politicians at all levels and to business leaders too, raising awareness in the workplace, with community groups, and among family and friends.


If enough of us are truly’climate clever’ in these ways and not merely ‘climate conned into ignoring the big picture, we will move the bounds of acceptability for governments and industry and make delay less and less viable for the few interests it serves.

And not wasting one’s political clout seems an appropriate place for me to end.

They say you are supposed to get more and more conservative as you get older and I was not a very radical young man. In fact when I was introduced at a Liberal Party meeting by a Townsville City Alderman in 1989 I was described as ’2I going on 40’.

Well in a couple of weeks I turn 40, and if you’d said to me at the age of 2I that, in 2007, I would be working hand in hand with Greenpeace or giving such a politically seditious speech during an election campaign at an event like this, I would have given you pretty amazing odds.

But such is life and such is the gravity of the challenge presented by climate change to this generation and those who follow us. It is forcing many people already, to challenge conventional or partisan assumptions, and, inevitably, it means doing things we never imagined possible to prevent equally unimaginable harm.

Hopefully my own actions of late will help others to seize that challenge and to confront the many other threats to our environment.


Read More......

Saturday, November 03, 2007

Howard: I won't sacrifice economic growth to cut greenhouse gas emissions

October 15, 2007
From TheAge (Aust)

Howard still refuses to sign the Kyoto protocol citing that we'd be at an unfair disadvantage as China and other developing nations aren't included as part of it.
That is true but short-sighted and an excuse for inaction. Specifically:


  • Kyoto Protocol is the legal basis for any international co-operation on climate change
  • Developed countries should face their historical responsibility and their high per-capita emissions
  • Australia has an 8% INCREASE over 1990 levels included in the Kyoto protocol. It is shameful we haven't even been able to stick to this
  • These Developing countries were almost nothing (no disrepect!) back in 1996 when the Kyoto Protocol was drawn up. What was the argument back then?
  • China and India have backed Kyoto and they are already meeting targets anyway!
  • Bush didn't sign Kyoto and thus a real reason for Howard not to
  • Howard is a luddite and lives in the past when polluting industries and coal in particular were king. The future is about efficiency and lean processes (minimal waste).




Prime Minister John Howard has dashed any hopes that he might end the government's Kyoto Protocol boycott, insisting he won't sacrifice economic growth to cut greenhouse gas emissions.

Mr Howard's first election campaign appearance on internet video site YouTube suggested the coalition would not be veering far from its existing climate change policy.

"The government will very shortly announce detailed plans on many issues including a climate change policy that balances our obligation to reduce greenhouse gas emissions with the need to keep our economy growing," he said.


The prime minister later reiterated his opposition to the Kyoto Protocol on economic grounds, but not necessarily its post-2012 successor.

"The reason I won't ratify the Kyoto treaty is: the existing Kyoto treaty doesn't cover countries like China, and we could be at a competitive disadvantage," he told Southern Cross Broadcasting.

"We'd be interested in ratifying a new international agreement that includes all of the major emitters because that would not put us at a competitive disadvantage."

Mr Howard's comment came after federal Environment Minister Malcolm Turnbull last week moved closer to accepting the Kyoto position by saying the government might sign an amended version for post-2012.

The independent Climate Institute argues that the necessary greenhouse gas cuts and a switch to clean energy can be made while sustaining economic growth.

"Government and independent groups such as ABARE and CSIRO show that strong economic growth is set to continue even if we substantially reduce emissions," chief executive John Connor said.

Federal Labor Leader Kevin Rudd says that ratifying the greenhouse blueprint would give Australia a greater say in climate change talks and help persuade China to commit on emissions cuts.

Mr Rudd said while the Kyoto treaty expires within five years, endorsing it would give the government a greater role in international climate change policy, starting at a Bali conference in December.

"If you haven't ratified Kyoto, you don't get to vote, that's the problem," he told Southern Cross.

"I want to be an international voice for Australia which is carving out the future arrangements."

Mr Rudd said China's argument for not accepting greenhouse targets had been because developed nations like Australia and the United States had refused to do so.

"Unless we in this country fix the China emissions problem with an international set of rules which bind both economies as well, then frankly our future is deeply compromised."

The Australian Greens have urged more federal investment in public transport as a way of tackling climate change.

Senator Kerry Nettle called on the commonwealth to ensure the states had the funding they needed to improve transport systems.

An environmental network gave both of the major parties low marks for their climate change policies, but put Labor ahead of the government.

Using nine criteria, The Big Switch gave the coalition a grade of 0.8 out of five and Labor 1.8.

National coordinator Tricia Phelan said Labor fell down by supporting the continued use of coal, while the coalition's response so far is "completely inadequate".

Read the article.


Read More......

Sunday, September 30, 2007

Howard's Kyoto resistance could be costing billion

September 9, 2007
From

THE Howard Government's refusal to sign up to the Kyoto Protocol to reduce greenhouse gases is costing Australian businesses about $3.8 billion a year, a study has found.

The report by respected environmental consultant Cambiar said the country was missing out on economic activity because local businesses could not fully participate in the $37.5 billion global carbon market, which last year alone tripled in value.

"This is the first time this analysis has been done and what we have found was that a significant opportunity has been forgone because we are not participating fully in the Kyoto process," Justin Sherrard, one of the report's authors, told The Sunday Age.

...

Read the article.

Read More......

Thursday, September 20, 2007

Exaggeration, Climate Change and the economic cost of climate change

Here is a blog about an article by Clive Hamilton.

WalkAgainstWarming2007_104

I was alerted to the article by Professor Sinclair Davidson (Economics Commentator and Collumnist), who was on Difference Of Opinion (http://abc.net.au/tv/differenceofopinion/) Thurs 20th Sept 2007. Professor Sinclair read the quote from Clive Hamilton in the newspaper article so out of context that it totally changed the meaning. Clive's statement went from meaning that there is a lot of exaggeration about Environmental and social matters and often times exaggeration is done for the sake of a strong emotional response. Clive went on to say that with Climate Change, the exaggeration has been by the Australian Federal government about the cost of tackling Climate Change. Sinclair Davidson used the quote "Environmentalists have often overstated the effects of environmental decline." without presenting the rest of Clive's argument.

This of course is typical of a climate change denier. The issue Clive presents about the Howard government is that not only have they failed to address climate change, but that they have purposely encouraged climate change through denial, policy setting and direct action such as "New Kyoto Protocol" (an excuse to try and distract the rest of the world from the true Kyoto Protocol). Guy Pearce discusses this in his book "High and Dry, John Howard, Climate Change and the Selling of Australia's Future" (see http://www.abc.net.au/ rn/latenightlive/ stories/2007/1967488.htm). And by Clive Hamilton in his book "Scorcher" (http://www.theage.com.au/ news/book-reviews/ scorcher-the-dirty-politics-of-climate-change /2007/05/25/1179601645988.html).

This information highlights that if you care about the environment and climate change, then do not believe any of the lies and green washing that the Howard Government is putting forward in their election campaign. They have some positive actions, but they are too little too late.

BTW, the Difference of Opinion program discussed what the Federal Government (post the election) should do with our large 20 billion surplus. Not is all as it seems! (http://www.abc.net.au/ reslib/200709/ r185236_688864.asx).



September 09, 2007
From Courier Mail

Article by Clive Hamilton.

WalkAgainstWarming2007_104

In the climate change debate, while the dangers of global warming have been deliberately understated, those opposed to taking action have engaged in absurd exaggeration of the economic costs of cutting emissions.

The Prime Minister, various ministers and the fossil fuel lobby have for years claimed that cutting emissions would be economically ruinous, cause massive job losses and destroy our international competitiveness. None of these claims is backed by credible evidence and can easily be shown to be false.

...

Read the article.

Read More......

Wednesday, August 22, 2007

130 jobs lost at wind turbine factory - Federal Govt to blame

August 22, 2007
From News.com.au


"The reason why Vestas has been unable to continue its operations in Portland is very squarely and directly as a result of the federal government's refusal to extend its renewable energy scheme to allow the industry to expand," he said on the ABC.


MORE than 130 manufacturing jobs will be lost in southwestern Victoria with a wind turbine blade factory set to close.

Vestas Wind Energy will close its Portland blade factory by the end of the year, saying it is not profitable enough.

"Vestas is regrettably compelled to close down its blade factory in Portland, Australia, effective from the year end," the Danish-based company's website said.

"The factory is not of a sufficient size to ensure satisfactory profitability, and the market outlook for Australia makes it impossible to expand the facility."

Opposition spokesman for regional development Denis Napthine said the factory closure was a bitter blow for the 136 workers and made a mockery of the state Government's promise of wind-energy jobs for country Victoria.

"It's absolutely imperative that the Brumby Government gets off its backside, gets down to Portland, talks to Vestas about keeping the factory open and keeping those jobs in Portland," he said on ABC radio.

"If they need assistance to grow the factory, to make it more efficient, the Government should assist."

Victorian Industry Minister Theo Theophanous has blamed the Commonwealth for failing to invest in renewable energy.

"The reason why Vestas has been unable to continue its operations in Portland is very squarely and directly as a result of the federal government's refusal to extend its renewable energy scheme to allow the industry to expand," he said on the ABC.

AWU state secretary Cesar Melhem also took aim at the Federal Government, citing its lack of vision and support for renewable energy.

"(Prime Minister) John Howard likes to say he is a good friend of the worker, but his Government fails time and time again to actually support the retention of good Aussie jobs," Mr Melhem said.

"Australians would much prefer to have their governments investing in local industries that provide good jobs and products, rather than having jobs sent offshore and poor quality goods imported."


Read the article.

Read More......

Tuesday, August 21, 2007

Bob Brown's Brilliance

On the recent "scandle" where the Australian Labor Party leader, Kevin Rudd (and likely next Prime Minister), got drunk in New York and went to a strip club, Bob Brown, the Australian Green's leader said:


"Four years ago Kevin Rudd got drunk and took himself into a strip club," Senator Brown said.
"Four years ago John Howard, sober, took Australia into the Iraq war.


See News article.

Read More......

Friday, June 29, 2007

Drop the fission line

Friday 29 June 2007
(URL for source to be found)
From Courier Mail, QLD, Australia

IMGP6918

Smart State ambassador Ian Lowe warns against a nuclear future

THE Queensland ALP conference this weekend offers an important forum for the Beattie Government to steer the state away from the risks of a radioactive future and towards sustainable energy options.

Prime Minister John Howard is actively promoting nuclear power as a belated answer to global climate change. Recent media reports suggest a wider federal nuclear agenda for Queensland that includes uranium enrichment and nuclear power.



Against this background it is important Premier Peter Beattie continues to keep the door firmly shut on uranium mining and the nuclear industry.

Uranium mining in Queensland would be economically short-sighted and environmentally disastrous. If we want to be the Smart State, we must use solar energy and other forms of renewables.

We should move towards better efficiency, turning our energy more effectively into the services we want. There are many more jobs and dollars in becoming a world leader in clean energy.

We have known for more than 20 years that burning coal, oil and gas is changing the global climate. Moves by the coal industry to clean up its act and reduce its pollution are welcome, but rushed pledges of taxpayer funding to assist this are not. The same money would do much more to curb greenhouse pollution if it were allocated to efficiency improvements and clean energy.

Some claim nuclear energy could help to slow climate change, but this is not a sensible solution. Even the Switkowski report, put together by a hand-picked group of pro-nuclear technocrats, did not make a convincing case.

The summary was optimistic, but the fine print of the report shows it would take about 15 years to build one nuclear power station if we started today, and the cost of electricity would more than double.

Even the most fanciful crash program, dotting 25 nuclear power stations all over the landscape, would only slow the growth in greenhouse pollution by less than 20 per cent. The science shows we need to make serious cuts, 60-90 per cent by 2050, not allow more increases.

Would uranium exports be an economic bonanza? No. The most optimistic forecast of the possible export income is about a third of our earnings from cheese exports. Uranium accounts for only about 1 per cent of our mineral exports and there is little prospect of it becoming a big earner.

What would be the cost of mining and exporting uranium? Huge volumes of radioactive mine tailings, depleted and degraded water resources and an increased risk from nuclear weapons and waste. We are still living with the legacy of the mines at Mary Kathleen and across the Northern Territory border at Rum Jungle.

Uranium mining needs large volumes of water -- not easy to find in Queensland at the moment -- and uses vast amounts of fossil energy, actually worsening greenhouse pollution.

Finally, as the Ranger uranium report said 30 years ago, uranium exports inevitably produce high-level radioactive waste that will have to be managed for hundreds of thousands of years and equally inevitably increase the risk of nuclear weapons.

Even if we say we have the best safeguards in the world and only export to the most responsible leaders, they won't be in power forever and can't control what others will do with the fissile material we sell.

We should learn the lesson of Iran. The world is now getting nervous about its possible nuclear developments. Thirty years ago, we were being urged to export uranium to Iran, and the US was trying to sell its nuclear technology to the Shah. Had that deal gone ahead, Iran would now have all it needs to build nuclear weapons.

The report A Bright Future showed we could get 25 per cent of our power from a mix of renewables by 2020. We should use solar hot water universally. Going that way would create literally thousands of real, skilled and permanent jobs in regional Australia.

Rather than facing a future of leaking tailings dams and increased pressure for nuclear reactors and waste dumps, Queensland can lead Australia and the world in sustainable and clean energy solutions.

The smart sunshine state is a much better option than being a toxic quarry.

Before last year's state election, the Premier stood firmly against the nuclear lobby and promised that the state would not support the mining or processing of uranium.

Beattie also resisted the silly suggestion that we should allow others to inflict on Queensland other stages of uranium processing, such as enrichment or dumping waste. As a Smart State ambassador, I strongly urge the Premier to resist those who want to drag us back into the Dark Age of uranium mining.

Ian Lowe is emeritus professor of science, technology and society at Griffith University and president of the Australian Conservation Foundation






...

Read the article.

Read More......

Wednesday, April 25, 2007

CSIRO contradicts PM over emission cuts

25 April 2007
From Blaney (Aust) - AAP article

Prime Minister John Howard says "I think it is crazy and irresponsible of any political party in this country to commit to a target when you don't know." He cited the Greens and Labor's cuts they would want to see.

But this article hightlights that a CSIRO report sent a month ago to Howard told him what the cuts would need to be and that they would not affect the economy greatly (if done now). (CSIRO are an Australian Government Research and Development group.) The Stern report also gave the same message and came from Nicholas Stern (from the UK Treasury):



So I'm still not understanding why John Howard doesn't have enough evidence to convince him to change the way he looks at the problem of climate change.

Read the article.

Read More......

Tim Flannery considered handing award back

Tuesday Apr 24
From NineMSN (Aust)

Mr Flannery said he was struggling to reconcile being Australian of the Year with the government's refusal to sign the Kyoto Protocol and the prime minister's belief that climate change is an economic issue — not a moral one.

Read the article.



Also see


Read More......

Monday, April 23, 2007

John Howard has absolutely no idea

John Howard visited Brisbane in Queensland (Australia) and demonstrated what a dinosaur he really is. He has no touch with reality. Economics is what is most important he has said many times in relation to Environmental matters. It is true that there is more to running a country than dealing with Climate Change, though it has to be accepted as a top priority and I don't believe Howard understands this. Some Environmentalists are argueing for a 90% reduction in GHG. The level of effort required for that would be significant and so our governments must not underestimate the task.

In the linked to article John Howard also singles out the USA and China as towering over us in terms of greenhouse gas emmisions. It reminds me of the poster of people sitting in a sinking rowboat. One end is high in the sky, the other is filling with water and being frantically bailed by the occupants at that end. The high and dry guy says "Not my problem". I'm trying to find that on the net somewhere now.

The fullpost below also contains a recent email conversation I had with some family members regarding our conservative Federal Liberal Government.

April 23, 2007
From Courier Mail

PRIME Minister John Howard today rejected Labor leader Kevin Rudd's claim that climate change was the overwhelming moral challenge facing Australians.
Mr Howard said Australia was a minor emitter of greenhouse gases and could not influence the global climate by acting alone.

The Prime Minister said he rejected the Labor Party's zealotry about the issue.

``Do we need to lower carbon emissions over time? Of course we do,'' he told the Queensland Media Club in Brisbane. ``But to say that climate change is the overwhelming moral challenge for this generation of Australians is misguided at best and misleading at worst.

``It de-legitimises other challenges over which we do have significant and immediate control.''

Mr Howard said such an approach also obscured the need for balanced government decision-making and fed ideological demands with kneejerk policy reactions.

Climate change was a serious policy challenge and a major priority of his government, he said.

``At the same time we know that independent action by Australia will not materially affect our climate,'' he said. ``Australia emits fewer greenhouse gases in a year than the United States and China emit in a month.''

Read the article.



Family email conversation


Greenpeace email


It all started from a Greenpeace game of guess how many times the Federal Treasurer will say Climate Change in the coming Federal Budget


From: "Greenpeace Australia Pacific"
Date: 20 April 2007 13:49:24 GMT+10:00
To:
Subject: Take a punt on Peter Costello


In the past 11 Federal Budgets, Treasurer Peter Costello hasnt even
mentioned the words climate change. Not once. And this year may be his
last chance.

Tell us how many times Costello will say climate change in his Budget
speech. If youre right, you go into the draw for a great solar backpack.

Vote Here: https://secure.greenpeace.org.au/budget2007/index1.html


Climate Change and the 2007 Budget

We have all been hearing plenty of talk about climate change lately and
the Government is starting to feel the heat after ignoring the issue for
so long.

The 2007 Federal Budget will be released on 8 May and this is a big
opportunity to take real action. Its where the Government actually puts
our money where their mouth is.

Climate change is Australias greatest threat. But every year, the
governments Budget actually helps fuel climate change by handing out over
a billion dollars of taxpayers money to the coal and fossil fuel industry.
Its hard to believe that our taxes are given to Australias richest
companies for them to pollute our future with greenhouse gas emissions.
Meanwhile, the solutions to global warming - Australias renewable energy
industries are overlooked every year.

Peter Costellos 2007 Budget speech on 8 May will show if the government
is serious about solutions to global warming. Take a punt on Peter now:
https://secure.greenpeace.org.au/budget2007/index1.html

If Costello wants to be PM, this could be his last chance. With an
election around the corner, his Budget needs to deliver what the voters
want a Big Switch that puts an end to fuelling climate change and
initiates renewable energy solutions.

Maybe Costello has been saving his best Budget for last.
How many times will he say climate change? Take a punt on Peter and
watch how he reacts:
https://secure.greenpeace.org.au/budget2007/index1.html

If you have trouble with any links in this email, you can take a punt on
Peter at the Greenpeace Australia Pacific website:
http://www.greenpeace.org/australia/

ML's email


I’d rather Costello spending sensibly on climate change than Rudd wasting it on unnecessarily rolling back an excellent track record of economic management and workplace reform.

Pity many voters don’t know what it is like to pay 17 percent on their home loan interest rate, under Rudd they will soon learn. Lets not forget the tragedy of labor administration and poor economic management.

LD's email



Thanks for letting us know how you vote ML.

This is the problem as I see it. It's not all about the economy. Or economic management.

And though I am not holding my breath I'd like to see any government with a focus on quality of life, which might happily mean less pay, less work hours, higher tax and a concentration on government spending where it will have long term benefits for future populations (ie. infrastructure, health education, hospitals, universities....).
So call me a leftie greenie intelligentsia, small l- liberal soft socialist dreamer and I'll thank you for the compliment !!!

Let me reiterate I know I'm dreaming, so you and those who vote with you are as safe as your (and my) mortgage !

I don't reckon Costello will mention climate change. He might say 'water crisis' or 'drought' or something else that implies the situation is temporary.

LD

ML's email


Thanks LD. Always happy to share the way I vote, I am a loud proud blue ribbon capitalist liberal.

The irony is never lost on me...Brooke working for this big quasi military company making squillions and ruining our earth, you running your own business, your family mostly farmers and me, the hard nosed capitalist working for the charity sector trying to make ends meet for the betterment of a sub-culture not ordinarily associated with capitalism, with an organisation that recycles, reuses and reduces everything it uses!!

You gotta love it!

:)

ML

Brooke's email


Gidday ML, LD and all,

Wow, I love a healthy discussion. BAL are big, and a small part of their business is involved in the military. It's unfortunate but true. The position of the military in our world has only been made more intense by Bush and the Coalition of the willing creating and supporting an unjust war. Prior to this, and when I joined BAL, the military was being used mainly for peaceful purposes (think Kosovo). Most of their business was in commercial aircraft.

You know my focus is not on Labor or any particular politics, except Green politics. Green politics includes social and environmental aspects, both of which the coalition government have such a poor record in. It's great that they have improved the economy, but at the cost of everything else. We are facing an enormous crisis at the moment, and it is the climate change deniers (John Howard was one until just before the Walk Against Warming held last November) that have been dragging this out for so long. Professor Ian Lowe (President of the ACF) co-wrote a papers in late the late 80's saying CO2 was increasing in the atmosphere and that it is causing climate change. Why has it taken so long to get momentum enough to have the world start to realise it needs to change - because deniers wouldn't take it seriously. The economy was king. Now Howard and similar parties are sproating tripe about fixing up the Environment would cost the economy (See Malcolm Turnbull on Lateline 29/3/2007 - http://www.abc.net.au/lateline/content/2007/s1885183.htm). That has been proved to be so wrong (see the Stern Report - http://www.hm-treasury.gov.uk/independent_reviews/stern_review_economics_climate_change/stern_review_report.cfm, http://environment.guardian.co.uk/climatechange/story/0,,1935211,00.html, http://mustelid.blogspot.com/2006/02/stern-report.html). So why would they continue to claim this? Because they are dinosaurs, they just don't get it. How can you have a growing economy when so much money will have to go into repairing our environment? Did you know that when the Kyoto Agreement was drawn up in 1995 that the level of CO2 reductions we had to meet was 12% on 1990 levels? And that today the level of reductions we have to meet are now atleast 60% (if not more with some like Monbiot saying 90% is the real target). The deniers dragging their feet have caused the bad economy we are about to see. You cannot convince me otherwise.

On the subject of people telling us ages ago that things have to change is the topic of Trees - Old Growth Forests, rainforests, remnant bushland and other forests. We have to stop tearing these down, we were told. But economy is king and we kept our destructive behaviours up. Its jobs after all, and we need to fuel the worlds appetite for paper and timber. How correct those 'greenies' / 'hippies' / 'environmentalists' were. We know that today. We know what an important position existing stands of trees play in a world loaded with too much carbon pollution. Yet our stupid economy-is-king based society STILL continues the crazy behaviour.

At BAL I am the chairman of the Environment Committee and have been in the group since it started back in 2003. We have implemented a number of initiatives including full recycling throughout, the removal of foam mugs (encouraging the use of normal mugs), water use reduction, educational sessions and external activities such as tree planting and clean up australia day. I don't know how much has been a result of our efforts, but Boeing Australia is employing an Environment Manager who will ensure that it reduces its environmental footprint (the B Company I believe is going this way also). We have a measure of 25% reduction in Greenhouse gas emisions year after year. The committee will discuss how we are going to achieve this. With BAL being a big consumer of resources, i think it is fantastic to work there and help make the changes. 2000 people or so work in Boeing Australia, and the changes we make will have a direct influence on how everybody there views the world. I am quite proud to be a part of this. BAL also pays me quite well and this gives me time to do volunteer work at Friends of the Earth and to lead Climate Action Brisbane who have organised the Brisbane Walks Against Warming in past years and will continue to do this plus persue other educational and action-based plans.

In conclusion, the economy-as-king attitude has helped ruin this planet. It is time for alternate environmentally-focused parties to lead us out of this mess and into better times. Does this mean our lives need to change? Once upon a time, not much though a bit more effort is required now. If we leave it any longer then it will mean more drastic changes will need to be made. You choose.

Regards,

Brooke

Read More......

Sunday, March 11, 2007

PM denies nuclear inquiry linked to big business


From ABC News (Aust)

This article discusses cronyism surrounding managing the climate change problem.

Our Prime Minister, John Howard, was a climate change denier until just before the Walk Against Warming last year (2006). Our group organised the Brisbane (Australia) event for this. It was held on November 4th, a very rainy day. Howard called the news about climate change "sensationalism" or similar. The pressure was too great, especially after the walk was held and he had to change his view to admit that it is true. The difference is that he may understand it to be true, but he doesn't believe it. He is not sincere to the changes that will come about due to it and the changes that need to be made to manage it. A very conservative man.

The so called world leaders started banging heads trying to tackle this problem and they amazingly decided that nuclear energy is the way to go. Howard is fully behind it. The article this links to talks about how Howard launched an inquiry into a nuclear powered australia and it just so happens that a mate of his has put together a plan on building a nuclear energy infrastructure in Australia. How convenient.

I agree that in many places in the world there are no valid alternatives, but in Australia we have oodles of sunshine, excessive amounts of wind, a giant coastline with lots of waves, geothermal power from hot rocks and so on. Nuclear does produce energy greenhouse gas (GHG) emission free, however the process also includes these nasties:


  • Mining of uranium takes enormous amounts of energy (producing GHG from fossil fuels to drive vehicles and coal) and always results in the poisoning of the local creeks, rivers and watertable;
  • Uranium processing also takes a lot of energy (GHGs mostly from coal that provides 80% of Australia's energy needs);
  • Transportation of the ore takes large amounts of energy (GHGs through fossil fueled engines)
  • In the 50 years that the world has had nuclear energy, NO SAFE METHOD OF DISPOSAL has been found, and the danger from the radiation lasts hundreds of thousands of years
  • The world is so fearful of terrorists. Surely a dirty bomb that uses nuclear waste is one of the scariest terror mechanism that terrorists could use


People need to understand ALL the facts before deciding what they want. I think if ALL the information is given to enough people, then nuclear power will never become a reality in Australia.

Read the article.

Read More......

Sunday, February 11, 2007

The biggest game on earth

Perhaps we are getting somewhere. I believe that Paul has painted a rosier picture than what is really being talked about in society. I've read a number of articles over the last couple days painting a picture of denial. One in the Australian yesterday yesterday used evidence from the IPCC report to say that ocean level rises would "only be" 50cm instead of Al Gore's pessimistic 6m that would wipe out New York. I believe that that figure of 50cm is the IPCC's expectation of up to 2050. Beyond that we could be looking at 6m. My point is, that I read a number of articles where people now admit Climate Change is real, but that the doomsday people are exagurating how bad it will be, and that there should be no need to worry about losing our currently beautiful lifestyles. We hate to say we told you so, and as vindication to us, we already have.

I'm going to copy in the entirety of this article since I read somewhere that The Australian is going to start charging for online access to their materials. This ofcourse will make it difficult to site their information online. I think this is a fucked mentality and a bad business decision. I won't pay for subscription - there are plenty of other news sources out there.



February 10, 2007
From The Australian.

Climate-change politics is a sleeping giant that has arisen, writes Paul Gilding.

LIKE many deeply involved in the climate change issue for the past 20 years, I've been feeling disoriented. Suddenly it's a top-order political issue, nationally and globally, and arguably the defining issue of our times. Carbon trading is just around the corner, conservative green politics has arrived and for consumers, paying for your carbon will soon be normal operating procedure.
In 30 years' involvement in social and environmental issues, I have never seen an issue move so fast or so dramatically as did this one in the spring of 2006. Nor have I been so excited at the potential for rapid, far-reaching change. So what happened and, more important, what happens now? Is this a genuine global environmental spring or is this some kind of weird drought-influenced aberration that will pass and normal transmission will then return?

And carbon pricing - what does it mean and how will it work? What are the implications for Australia and for key industries? With the arrival of "conservative green", will politics in Australia be the same again?

Let's start with the science which is worth revisiting briefly for one reason. Unlike most other market and political questions, where the uncertainties of human behaviour, technology and political trends make predicting the future a dangerous though interesting activity, climate change is different.

It is driven by science, by physical realities, like the heat-trapping nature of greenhouse gases. We put more CO2 pollution in the atmosphere and more heat will

be trapped. If it gets hotter, the climate will change.

So as the science became accepted over recent years, the direction of the market became crystal clear. People, including some titans of industry, thought it through. They realised if this relationship is a fact, and the effects we see are already significantly negative, such as our hopefully soon-to-break drought, then the future suddenly looks deeply unstable, potentially catastrophically so. The conclusion: time to act.

Enter John Howard. The point that marked the end of the climate-change winter in Australian politics was the Prime Minister's long interview on Four Corners on August 28 last year. Our most brilliant politician looked unusually uncomfortable and clearly offside on a leading issue. Critically in this case, he looked out of touch with much of corporate Australia, whose interests he was defending. People who monitor these issues had two reactions to the PM's interview. Some thought well, that's it, this long winter of inaction and denial will continue as long as Howard is in charge. He clearly will not shift and therefore this country will not shift for many years.

Others, including myself, said, "No, this is the end, the thaw is on." It's not just the icecaps that are melting. Howard, master of his craft, would not stay out of touch with the people in an election year. He'd flip like a circus acrobat, and make climate action look like part of the plan all along.

There was something else at work. For several years I have had many influential chiefs of Australian business talk to me privately about their increasing frustration with the Government's lack of action on climate. They saw the science, they saw the future and they were worried. They were worried for their children and yes, corporate chiefs do worry about their children's future and deeply so.

But more immediately they were worried about the Australian economy and their own companies' ability to grow and succeed. So they started to talk to each other, privately and in hushed tones, aware that they were coming up against the government of the day and a PM who had decreed supporting strong action on climate to be politically incorrect. Yet their frustrations were steadily building.

The dam started to crack when a group of large corporates, mainly Business Council of Australia members, teamed up to form the Business Roundtable on Climate Change. They hoped for safety in numbers.

Working with the Australian Conservation Foundation, they commissioned research into what needed to be done and what it would cost to act, or not to. They concluded heavily in favour of early action because it was cheaper. They released their report in April 2006, triggering a collapse in the business community's opposition to pricing carbon.

Mike Hawker from IAG, Gerry Hueston from BP, David Morgan from Westpac, Grant King from Origin and Harry Debney from Visy stood up and faced their political fears. They said, "We want dramatic cuts in CO2, we want a long, loud and clear legal framework to achieve those cuts and we want a tradeable price on carbon. And we want it soon."

The politics of climate change started to tremble. Here was big business asking for regulation on an environmental issue. Things were getting interesting.

And they weren't alone. In August 2006, another recent convert to the cause of conservative green, John Schubert, chairman of the Commonwealth Bank, board member of Qantas and former head of the BCA, stood up at the Davos Connection's annual Hayman Island Leadership Retreat for business, political and media leaders and asked everyone to watch Al Gore's film, An Inconvenient Truth. To make it easier he'd arranged a pre-release screening that evening. Schubert is deeply concerned that the Great Barrier Reef is threatened by climate change. (The irony of Schubert doing this was delicious, having built his career at Exxon, the company environmentalists unaffectionately refer to as the "death star" for its singular focus on preventing the world acting on climate change.) The next day on Hayman Island, ANZ chief John McFarlane electrified the meeting with a speech in which he invoked the moral imperative, saying he stood there not as a business leader, but as a person. He called for urgent and significant unilateral action in Australia. The future is in our hands he said, so what will we do?

One by one, all these people went off to Canberra. Directly and indirectly the message got through to the PM's office. The people at resource giant Rio Tinto, who had picked up former WMC boss Hugh Morgan's mantle, as the strongest advocate to government for

delay and prevarication, had been outmanoeuvred. It was game on. The power of the market had spoken.

The rest is history. Gore's movie and his Australian tours sparked media attention. Nicholas Stern's report in Britain argued this was an issue with economic impact comparable to a depression and a couple of world wars simultaneously. The worst drought on record drove that point home, pointing out the cost of climate change and therefore the cost of not acting. The public engaged deeply and even the tabloid press and breakfast television picked it up. And then the arrival of that most fascinating of political competitions between the two rising stars of Australian politics, Malcolm Turnbull and Peter Garrett.

So my belief is we will have a price on carbon in Australia, with a national trading scheme agreed to within a few years. The argument is only who pays it, who gets it for free to start with (known as "grandfathering" to protect existing industries and assets), and when do we start trading. Grandfathering is actually a good term, because it's about protecting the old fellas we're quite fond of, who worked hard in years gone by, but are now past their prime and need a bit of looking after. So what will carbon trading look like, why do so many companies want it and what will it mean for consumers?

First, let's put to bed any doubt that this is a global business issue and not an Australian, drought-induced political phenomenon. In the US in January, an extraordinary coalition of companies with a combined market capitalisation of more than $US750 billion ($963 billion), called for strong climate action. If you think it was hard for our business leaders to confront Howard, imagine how US CEOs felt approaching George W. Bush. But they did: Alcoa, BP, Caterpillar, Duke Energy, GE, DuPont, PG&E, Lehman Brothers and others spoke loud and clear. They called for fast, strong national legislation mandating significant CO2 cuts and a cap and trade system to deliver it.

In Australia, there is also a powerful argument to have a national system now rather than waiting for the world. No one wants their nation to be the Argentina of the 21st century, falling from wealth and privilege to economic basket case through lack of foresight. Resource-dependent, export-focused countries are risky long-term propositions. Australia's natural resource wealth is a good foundation that we should leverage, but unless we adapt to a changing market we could soon go into decline. To avoid this, we need to build a smart, adaptable, low-carbon economy. Carbon trading can facilitate this: for the country, for companies and for consumers. It prepares us for the inevitable transition.

The reason many in big business are excited about carbon trading, even though by definition putting a price on carbon increases costs, is that it allows clever companies to grab some of the value that gets transferred around the economy as a result. The opportunity in Australia alone is huge. Consider these numbers. To stabilise the climate, we have to cut CO2 pollution dramatically to about 20 per cent to 40 per cent of 1990 levels by 2050. The gap between business-as-usual and even a 60 per cent cut by 2050 is about 13 billion tonnes of CO2 and its equivalents. Put a conservative price on carbon of say $15 a tonne and that's about $200 billion of value that can be applied to the infrastructure and technology developments we need to close that gap.

The economic impact, however, is even greater, because that value is applied not in isolation as an investment but to cover the incremental additional costs of clean technologies over dirty technologies. Assume that's a 35per cent increment and we're talking about facilitating $800 billion of investment in the solution. This is a very serious economic issue and a very serious business opportunity. From light bulbs to power stations, we're about to invest big-time. The corporate sector gets it and the consumer will soon feel it.

To understand how carbon trading works, just look at NSW, where a limited state carbon market is already operating. Since the system first started in 2003, about 37 million tonnes have been traded with a value of more than $400 million. Where does the money come from and where does it go? It comes from electricity users, who in NSW now pay a small amount extra on each kilowatt of power they use. That explains part of the future; we'll all pay more for our emissions of carbon, embedded into every thing we buy, and we'll all benefit from less pollution.

Where does the money go in the NSW scheme? It pays for activities that reduce future CO2 emissions. TRUenergy, for example, is building a new gas-fired power station at Tallawarra in NSW, that wouldn't have been economic except that it generates carbon credits they can sell, because it's so much cleaner than the best coal plant.

For consumers in NSW, it works out to be a good deal as well. They pay more per unit of electricity, but they get help to cut their actual electricity bill. A company I lead, Easy Being Green, distributed three million high-efficiency light bulbs in 2006 to 500,000 homes, cutting each of our customers' electricity bills. At our peak in that project we were employing 240 people to distribute the globes and also water-saving showerheads.

Now we're going into homes and installing the globes directly. Our people trade carbon with individuals every day. The transaction is simple. We'll give you this equipment that will cut your power consumption, therefore cut your indirect CO2 emissions and reduce your annual power bill, by more than $100. You give us the rights to the Co2 you save and we'll sell it under the NSW carbon trading scheme to pay for the globes and our costs. So even with a higher price per unit of electricity, their overall power bill can go down. Very good economics, and even better politics.

Roll this out across the economy and the transition begins. Large amounts of value are transferred around the economy. Those who cut emissions win and those who don't, pay. Those companies that respond quickly to the opportunities will succeed; those that prevaricate will lose. Entrepreneurs will seize the opportunity and massive amounts of capital will flow to those that get it right, while others will go broke trying. This is the creative destruction of capitalism at work, and it's why a well-designed market is our best hope. Getting the system design right is the key job for governments, which takes us back to politics.

Will Howard get it in time? Maybe, maybe not. He stumbled this week, and forgot his lines. He's not good when he doesn't believe what he's saying and on this one, he doesn't yet get it. His problem, and I suspect Kevin Rudd's as well, is that he sees the environment as an important issue to be managed, an issue the voters care about, so important for political reasons.

However, climate change is no longer just an environmental issue nor a temporary political issue. This is a geopolitical, economic and social challenge with the potential to redirect civilisation. It's the biggest game on earth and many will be left in its wake, wondering what hit them, perhaps some of the world's most successful corporations such as ExxonMobil, and perhaps one of Australia's most successful politicians. We are entering a different world. Deep turbulence is ahead. Hold on for the ride.

Paul Gilding has spent 30 years involved with environmental issues as an activist and business leader. He founded Ecos Corporation and is chief executive officer of consumer company Easy Being Green. He was international executive director of Greenpeace in the 1990s.
Read the article.



Read More......

Saturday, February 10, 2007

flannery: 'No justification' for coal exports

February 08, 2007
From News.com (Aust).


AUSTRALIA can no longer justify its coal exports in the face of global warming fuelled by burning the commodity, Australian of the Year Tim Flannery said.

The Federal Government is counting on Australian-made clean coal technology being used to clean up coal-fired power stations in China and India.

With hundreds of coal-fired power stations due to be commissioned in developing nations in the coming years, the government has committed $6 million to help China work out how it can use new low-emission technology in their existing power stations.

But Professor Flannery said exporting coal could no longer be considered to be in Australia's national interest.

"That time has already come and the social licence of coal to operate is rapidly being withdrawn globally, and no government can protect an industry from that sort of thing occurring," he told ABC TV's Lateline program.

"We've seen it with asbestos, we'll see it with coal.

"We have to deal with that issue if we want a stable climate."

Prime Minister John Howard this week ruled out regulating Australia's lucrative coal exports to ensure it was only used in power stations employing cleaner technology, saying it would be a knee-jerk response that would damage the economy.

The Government should not bank on cleaner coal technology to solve the problem, Prof Flannery said.

"The technology is going to be too small and come too late to fix the problem," he said.

"The problem has grown too big now to be fixed. We need real investment from Government, real sacrifice at the moment for a better future."

Mr Howard also has said he feared that if China stopped using Australian coal the country would use a dirtier domestic product and make the situation worse.

Prof Flannery said that argument was "a false equation".

"The Europeans are already talking about tariffs, carbon-based tariffs," he said.

"As the situation unfolds and matters get more critical, the world is not going to allow people to pollute our common atmosphere.

"The social licence to operate those old polluting technologies would be withdrawn."

The Howard Government had made matters worse for itself by failing to ratify the Kyoto pact which dealt with the unwanted consequences of the coal trade, Prof Flannery said.

"If we'd done that 10 years ago we may have lessened the damage that was being done and we may have been on a trajectory that was healing the planet," he said.

"We didn't do that, so now the medicine we have to take has to be more radical."

Read the article.

Also see



Read More......

Thursday, February 01, 2007

Coastal sites flagged for nuke reactors

Tuesday Jan 30 22:35 AEDT
From http://news.ninemsn.com.au

Nuclear reactors are likely to be spaced out along the Australian coast from Townsville in Queensland to Port Augusta in South Australia under a nuclear-powered future, a new study says.

Queensland would have six reactors and the coast around Sydney from Port Stephens to Jervis Bay would have four power plants, left-wing think-tank the Australia Institute says.

Victoria would have four more and South Australia three, including one at Port Adelaide, it suggests.

In all, the study names 17 likely sites for reactors, based on criteria such as proximity to seawater for cooling and access to the national electricity grid.

The institute also surveyed 1,200 Australians on their attitude towards having a reactor in their local area and found that 66 per cent were opposed.

A quarter of those surveyed, 25 per cent, were supportive and nine per cent undecided.

Fifty-five per cent were strongly opposed and just 10 per cent strongly in favour.

The study follows a determined push by the federal government towards the nuclear generation of electricity.

A government commissioned inquiry headed by Dr Ziggy Switkowski last year reported reactors would have to be positioned within tens of kilometres of the east coast national power grid.

It found that nuclear generation was attractive in the battle against greenhouse gas emissions and could be viable if there were to be a price on carbon.

That inquiry posed the scenario of 25 reactors producing a third of Australia's electricity needs by the year 2050.

The institute's director Dr Clive Hamilton said overseas experience showed that the siting of power plants is one of the most politically contentious aspects of the nuclear debate.

"The prime minister has called for a thorough and full-blooded debate about nuclear energy," Dr Hamilton said.

"We cannot have this debate without considering siting issues."

Report author Andrew Macintosh said the fact that nuclear energy attracted moderate levels of support at a general level but fierce opposition from local communities when concrete proposals were put forward suggested the presence of the not-in-my-backyard (NIMBY) phenomenon.

"That is, even if people do not oppose nuclear power plants at a general level, they often object to proposals to construct them in their local areas," he said.

The report raised the possibility that governments might compensate communities in a bid to placate local opposition to nuclear facilities.

Industry Minister Ian Macfarlane declined to comment on the report, saying the nuclear debate was too young to be talking about placement of reactors.

"It's too early to start speculating," a spokeswoman for Mr Macfarlane told AAP.

"He just wants to talk about it and start investigating it. Deciding on sites is something that's going to happen way down the track."

Labor's resources and energy spokesman Chris Evans said people in the communities identified by the report should expect a nuclear power plant in their area if Prime Minister John Howard's nuclear plans are successful.

Labor is opposed to a nuclear industry in Australia.

"Instead of talking up nuclear power John Howard should be encouraging an immediate increase in the use of renewable energy and the introduction of clean coal technologies," Senator Evans said.

"With Australia's existing energy resources, there is no reason for us to go down the nuclear path."

Labor's environment spokesman Peter Garrett said the report was further evidence Australia should not go nuclear.

"Australia needs to go on a low carbon diet, not a nuclear binge, and these figures show John Howard is increasingly out of step with Australians who are desperate for real action on climate change," he said.

Greens senator Kerry Nettle said the report unsurprisingly showed that populations close to the suggested sites did not want nuclear power plants.

"Instead of talking about 25 possible nuclear power plants, the prime minister should be looking for another 25 sites for major wind power stations and another 25 solar power stations," she said.

Read the article.

Read More......

Saturday, January 20, 2007

Clean energy pact a 'diversion'

January 16, 2007 12:00
From http://www.news.com.au/

PRIME Minister John Howard's pact with China to use so-called clean coal technology was a typical diversion from the need to switch from coal to renewable energy, Greenpeace said today.

The environmental group said Mr Howard continued to ignore options that would deter industrialised economies from increasing greenhouse gas emissions.

Australia and China yesterday pledged to work together to develop cleaner energy alternatives following top level talks in the Philippines.

The pact coincided with a wider declaration on energy security made by 16 countries at the East Asia Summit (EAS) of regional leaders.

The declaration pledges a move towards nuclear and other alternative energy solutions, acknowledging the need for renewable energy development.

But Greenpeace spokesman Ben Pearson said China was already moving in that direction, having recently announced plans to invest 45.6 billion yuan ($7.41 billion) to more than triple wind power generation capacity by 2010 and aiming to reach a 15 per cent renewable energy target by 2020.

"This is the real solution to climate change and what Australia should be promoting," Mr Pearson said.

"The deal seems to involve no new financing and doesn't address the central problem that without a price on carbon, technologies such as geosequestration will never be commercially deployed.

"Moreover, it will be at least 10 years before we know if geosequestration even works, which is simply too late."

Mr Pearson said deep cuts were needed in greenhouse emissions of industrialised countries of at least 30 per cent by 2020 to avoid dangerous climate change.

"We may not even know if geosequestration will work by then," he said.

Read the article.

Read More......