Showing posts with label new international. Show all posts
Showing posts with label new international. Show all posts

Sunday, February 11, 2007

Cost of climate change


From New Internationalist and George Monbiot's book "Heat".

George Monbiot resists the urge to do battle in a fog of meaningless statistics.

Now that the dismissal of climate change is no longer fashionable, the professional deniers are trying another means of stopping us from taking action. It would be cheaper, they say, to wait for the impacts of climate change and then adapt to them. They have the figures to prove it. It is tempting to prove them wrong. Given the new projections of major drought in continental interiors, of a possible global food deficit, of sea level rises with the potential to affect billions of people, it should be easy to demonstrate that the price of waiting for the catastrophe is higher than the price of reducing emissions. But it’s a temptation we should resist. Such calculations use costs which simply cannot be compared. The most famous exponent of the comparison is the Danish statistician Bjørn Lomborg. In his book The Skeptical Environmentalist, he argues that the cost of doing nothing about climate change – of letting nature take its course – is $4,820 billion. The cost of stabilizing global temperatures at 2.5° above the 1990 level would be $8,553 billion; and the cost of stabilising them at 1.5° above the 1990 level would be $37,632 billion. He warns that ‘with the best intentions of doing something about global warming we could end up burdening the global community with a cost much higher or even twice that of global warming alone’. It would be better to use our money to make investments with higher returns, leaving ‘future generations of poor people with far greater resources’.

Many environmentalists have taken him to task, claiming that his costs for taking action are too high and his costs for the impacts of climate change are too low. But they have been drawn into a fake debate. For while the costs of taking action can reasonably be measured in dollars, most of the costs of climate change cannot.

We are told, for example, that the financial costs of Hurricane Katrina, which may have been exacerbated by climate change, amount to some $75 billion, and we can use that number to help derive a price for carbon pollution. But does it capture the suffering of the people whose homes were destroyed? Does it reflect the partial destruction, in New Orleans, of one of the quirkiest and most creative communities on earth? Does it, most importantly, measure the value of the lives of those who drowned?

In other words, is it possible to place an economic price on human life? Or on an ecosystem, or on the climate? Could such costs, when rolled out around the world, really be deemed to amount to $4,820 billion, give or take the odd dollar? Such figures are not just wrong. They are meaningless.

When economists have tried to put a price on such things, they have simply exposed the limitations of their science. In 1996, for example, a study for the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change estimated that a life lost in the poor nations could be priced at $150,000, while a life lost in the rich nations could be assessed at $1.5 million. The researchers produced these figures by estimating how much people would be prepared to pay for the adaptive measures that would save their lives. Unsurprisingly, they discovered that the lives of rich people were worth more than the lives of poor people.

These days, economists are less prepared to expose themselves to ridicule. So anything that cannot be quantified is simply excluded from the balance sheet. What this means is that the loss of all the really important things – a functioning ecosystem, human communities, human life – is overlooked. Because they aren’t counted, they don’t count.

It would be wrong to blame only Bjørn Lomborg and the economists whose work he promotes for taking this line. Almost everyone feels obliged to attach a price tag to global catastrophe. The British Government, for example, has decided that the ‘social cost’ of carbon emissions is somewhere between $60 and $250 per tonne, with a middle value of $120. We might reasonably ask what the heck this means. Does the British Government really believe it can put a price on the people of Africa? On Bangladesh?

...

Read the article.

Read More......

Sunday, January 14, 2007

10 things you should know about tree 'offsets'

I recently blogged about Dell going Carbon Neutral.

My point was that a major electronics company is taking this seriously, where-as another (Apple) isn't, atleast to the extent required (I discussed this in How green is my Apple). This post was not an endorsment to carbon offsets as a solution to climate change. Climate Action Brisbane, Friends of the Earth and many other groups do not support them. Carbon offsets is the first step to world-wide agreement. Carbon Quota / Rationing is the next. This is discussed in length in George Monbiot's book "Heat".

The reasons we don't support carbon offsets as a solution to climate change is discussed in this New International article. The key points are below:

Active Carbon Pool


Carbon moves between forests, atmosphere and oceans in a complex natural rhythm of daily/seasonal/annual and multi-annual cycles. The overall amount in all three carbon stores together rarely increases in nature. This is ‘active’ carbon.

Fossil Carbon Pool


Some carbon is locked away and rarely comes into contact with the atmosphere naturally. This ‘fossil carbon’ is stored permanently in coal, oil and gas deposits and therefore is not part of the active carbon pool. When humans mine and extract these reserves this inactive fossil carbon does not go back in the ground, but is added into the active carbon pool, disrupting a delicate balance.

This is one of the reasons that the concept of ‘offsets’ is flawed. Offsets allow extraction of oil, coal and gas to continue, which in turn increases the amount of fossil carbon that is released into the active carbon pool disrupting the cycle. That is why campaigners argue that genuine solutions to climate change require us to keep fossil carbon (oil, coal and gas) in the ground.


The ten reasons are:

  1. Carbon in trees is temporary (Trees can easily release carbon into the atmosphere through fire, disease, climatic changes, natural decay and timber harvesting);
  2. One-way road (the carbon in fossil fuels is safely locked away until mined);
  3. Fake credit (carbon offsets is a false economy);
  4. Big foot (the ecological footprint, or space to plant trees of offset the amount of carbon we currently release is too great - we need space for food crops and even for crops for bio-fuels (which take away from space from food crops so they too are not a solution);
  5. Subsidies for mega-plantations (carbon offsets will support and subsidise plantations, and these are not desired for other reasons aswell as the above));
  6. Communities suffer twice (indigenous and forest dependant communities not only suffer from climate change but from their land which will be taken over by plantations);
  7. Ticking time bomb (drastic actions are required - carbon offsets just allow business to continue as usual and does not address the real changes that need to be made);
  8. Forest fraud (we should be leaving the forest in areas such as the Amazon and South East Asia - some of the most heavily logged areas in the world - not knocking them down and starting monoculture plantations);
  9. Blind guess (it is an unreliable science in carbon offsets - it is truly difficult to measure what is saved with what was released);
  10. The tenth reason is a sumarisation of the above - Carbon credits from tree planting are a phony climate fix.


The lead article to the above is at If you go down to the woods today....

From it I extract another reason:

  • That carbon offsets have become a business which values money over the true intention of reducing the carbon in our atmosphere. It's just capitalism in another guise.


From the story:

A report in the Sunday Telegraph stated that, of the 10,000 trees that were supposedly distributed to small farmers in this largely dry Indian state, only a few hundred were found to be still alive. The rest perished through lack of water and inadequate financial and infrastructure support from the Carbon Neutral Company and its partners.

One of the project participants, Anandi Sharan Mieli of Women for Sustainable Development, accused the Carbon Neutral Company of having a ‘condescending’ attitude. ‘They do it for their interests, not really for reducing emissions. They do it because it’s good money,’ she was quoted as saying. The Carbon Neutral Company, however, blames Mieli’s group for not meeting its ‘contractual obligations’ to provide the necessary irrigation and support.


Also see:


The lust for money over everything else is responsible for 100% of the human caused reasons why we are in this mess today. In my own opinion, we will not be able to solve the climate crisis, along with the social injustice that perpetuates it, whilst capitalism is at the helm steering planet people.

Read More......