Showing posts with label greenwashing. Show all posts
Showing posts with label greenwashing. Show all posts

Saturday, February 24, 2007

Carbon Offset Companies Using Enron Style Accounting

February 20th, 2007
From Price Of Oil.

A new report from Climate Trade Watch, which is affiliated to the Transnational Institute, accuses carbon offset companies of using the same sort of ‘future value accounting’ that caused the collapse of energy giant Enron.

The report argues that when companies like Climate Care and the Carbon Neutral Company sell the public carbon offsets, carbon savings expected to be made in the future are counted as savings made in the present. This is known as ‘future value accounting’ and is the same technique used by Enron to inflate its profits with such disastrous consequences.


Offset companies give the idea that emissions are instantly ‘neutralised’ when in fact the supposed ‘neutralisation’ can take place over periods of up to a hundred years. Regular offsetting worsens the problem because the rate at which carbon emissions are ‘neutralised’ is far slower than the rate at which they are generated.

The report also argues that offset companies breed complacency by selling ‘peace of mind’ to consumers, offering up a form of ‘greenwash’ that distracts from the serious task of tackling unsustainable consumption patterns and business practices

Moreover there has been limited research on the climate benefits of tree plantations into the carbon cycle while the offset companies quantify this supposed benefit into a sellable commodity.

The report’s author, Kevin Smith, said that “The only effective way of dealing with climate change is to dramatically decrease our current rates of fossil fuel consumption. Offsets are providing a justification to maintain our carbon-intensive lifestyles, and delaying the profound changes we need to make in our societies”.

Read the article.
Or see the Full report.


Read More......

Tuesday, January 16, 2007

M&S to spend £200m on green strategy

The Coles Myer and Woolworths giants have been looking for something that distinguishes themselves for the other. Being Australian companies they also are unable to pioneer anything for themselves. NOW Marks and Spencer in Great Britain have presented the answer to them - go as green as possible. Hopefully they'll take note. I'm sure US people could say the same about their giants (mmm, I think read somewhere that Walmart is going super-green also - excellent, more of a reason for Coles Myer / Woolworths to do so also.

I also need to add that I write this blog entry with the realisation that what Marks & Spencer are doing will most likely not be the solution, though it will be a step in the right direction that will encourage change in the shopping industry (just like Dell are doing in the electronics industry). Things do have to happen in small steps (unfortunately if George Monbiot is correct then these small steps had better come quickly and successively after one-another if we are to achieve 90% reduction in Greenhouse Gases by 2030. A other hope it that what M & S (and the others are doing) isn't just Greenwashing which will get us nowhere at any time.




by Sarah Butler

Marks & Spencer plans to spend £200 million over the next five years on going green as the battle to become the most environmentally friendly retailer steps up.

The high street giant, which launches its strategy with an advertising campaign in March, has set some challenging targets, including a pledge to stop sending all waste to landfill and to reduce CO2 emissions by 80 per cent.

However, the aspirations will be closely scrutinised by non-governmental organisations, which will want to see if M&S will be able to maintain its commitment to them in future years as the deadline to meet its targets near. Stuart Rose, the chief executive, said that he hoped that the cost of the programme would be offset by increased sales.

Last year the retailer launched a Behind the Label campaign, which highlighted Marks & Spencer’s environmental and ethical business practices and was one of the retailer’s most successful advertising schemes.

Mr Rose said: “We think this is the right thing to do because our customers, employees and, increasingly, shareholders are asking us to. We believe those people will embrace a responsible business.”

M&S has worked on the project for six months, taking advice from Jonathon Porritt, the former director of Friends of the Earth, who said: “This plan raises the bar for everyone else — not just retailers but businesses in every sector.”

M&S’s detailed 100-point plan covers climate change, waste, raw materials, fair trade and healthy living.

...


Read the article.

Read More......